OT: OT: Lets Go Cardinals! (All Baseball Talk Here) Part 2

TheDizee

Trade Jordan Kyrou ASAP | ALWAYS RIGHT
Apr 5, 2014
20,484
13,091


WOOHOOOO, GO MO GO!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bobby Orrtuzzo

Allens Five Hole

Registered User
Jan 17, 2017
234
235
I honestly think any off Swanson, Bogaerts, or Turner would be fantastic pickups for SS. Murphy from the As or Contreras would be good for the C position.

The nice thing about some players we have like Edman and Donovan is their ability to play the middle infield and the OF corners. Then we have nice young power hitters like Yepez and Gorman for the DH as long as they don't hit a wall and continue to hit like last year.

Definitely need Carlson and O'Neill (if they don't trade him) to be healthy this year tho.
Please no Swanson. His BABIP was an extreme outlier and whoever signs him long term will regret it very quickly.

The Cards NEED an everyday LH bat. Trading for Jesse Winker now that the Mariners have created a logjam in OF would be a decent move. I would love to sign Bellinger now that he’s an FA. There’s obvious upside with him.
 

yurnxt

Registered User
Apr 7, 2009
409
392
Cardinals should trade whatever it takes outside of Winn and Walker to grab Ohanti. His massive marketability here and abroad should offset some of the cost of an extension and he would help the club in two of the ways we need it most... A reliable, strike out machine ace and a badass #3 left handed hitter to sandwich between Arenado and Goldschmidt giving the Cardinals probably the best 3 consecutive hitters of any lineup in the game while creating disastrous late game bullpen matchup problems for the opposing team.

99% complete pipedream but still...
 

TheDizee

Trade Jordan Kyrou ASAP | ALWAYS RIGHT
Apr 5, 2014
20,484
13,091
Cardinals should trade whatever it takes outside of Winn and Walker to grab Ohanti. His massive marketability here and abroad should offset some of the cost of an extension and he would help the club in two of the ways we need it most... A reliable, strike out machine ace and a badass #3 left handed hitter to sandwich between Arenado and Goldschmidt giving the Cardinals probably the best 3 consecutive hitters of any lineup in the game while creating disastrous late game bullpen matchup problems for the opposing team.

99% complete pipedream but still...
any cheap 5 dollar dumpster dive versions of him available?
 

Allens Five Hole

Registered User
Jan 17, 2017
234
235
Cardinals should trade whatever it takes outside of Winn and Walker to grab Ohanti. His massive marketability here and abroad should offset some of the cost of an extension and he would help the club in two of the ways we need it most... A reliable, strike out machine ace and a badass #3 left handed hitter to sandwich between Arenado and Goldschmidt giving the Cardinals probably the best 3 consecutive hitters of any lineup in the game while creating disastrous late game bullpen matchup problems for the opposing team.

99% complete pipedream but still...
There is no chance that the Angels take a deal that doesn't involve any organization's first overall prospect (Walker) and its likely that it'd require your first 2 or 3 top prospects, an MLB ready young player with upside and maybe more.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Bye Bye Blueston

Linkens Mastery

Conductor of the TankTown Express
Jan 15, 2014
20,392
18,108
Hyrule
Cardinals should trade whatever it takes outside of Winn and Walker to grab Ohanti. His massive marketability here and abroad should offset some of the cost of an extension and he would help the club in two of the ways we need it most... A reliable, strike out machine ace and a badass #3 left handed hitter to sandwich between Arenado and Goldschmidt giving the Cardinals probably the best 3 consecutive hitters of any lineup in the game while creating disastrous late game bullpen matchup problems for the opposing team.

99% complete pipedream but still...
Angels are not trading Ohtani before the season starts.
 

Linkens Mastery

Conductor of the TankTown Express
Jan 15, 2014
20,392
18,108
Hyrule
I'm torn. Jansen would definitely be an upgrade over Kiz. But, we are already kinda bare in the Outfield after O'Neill-Carlson-Nootbaar. Until Walker projects longterm in the OF and Burleson takes the next step.
 
  • Like
Reactions: hockeywiz542

Memento

Future Authoress.
Sep 12, 2011
1,237
1,584
St. Louis, Missouri
I'm torn. Jansen would definitely be an upgrade over Kiz. But, we are already kinda bare in the Outfield after O'Neill-Carlson-Nootbaar. Until Walker projects longterm in the OF and Burleson takes the next step.

Burleson has been a plus hitter since we've drafted him, and he's developed a lot of power as well. Moises Gomez, who led the Minors in home runs, was added to the 40 recently. Walker is going to be in the outfield by 2023; it's only a matter of when. I could even see someone like Gorman take occasional reps in the outfield; he already has a good arm. We even signed Oscar Mercado to a minor league deal, and he could be another option.

We're not lacking in outfielders. I could even see us trading O'Neill as well as Nootbaar if Walker and Burleson prove to be as advertised.
 

Linkens Mastery

Conductor of the TankTown Express
Jan 15, 2014
20,392
18,108
Hyrule
Burleson has been a plus hitter since we've drafted him, and he's developed a lot of power as well. Moises Gomez, who led the Minors in home runs, was added to the 40 recently. Walker is going to be in the outfield by 2023; it's only a matter of when. I could even see someone like Gorman take occasional reps in the outfield; he already has a good arm. We even signed Oscar Mercado to a minor league deal, and he could be another option.

We're not lacking in outfielders. I could even see us trading O'Neill as well as Nootbaar if Walker and Burleson prove to be as advertised.
I truly think Burleson is going to be a very good outfielder (first jersey I've ever bought of a prospect in any major sport). I'm just worried that they aren't ready yet. And then we go into next year with Walker-Carlson-Burleson and we find out they aren't anywhere close to ready.
 

TheDizee

Trade Jordan Kyrou ASAP | ALWAYS RIGHT
Apr 5, 2014
20,484
13,091
Fix5ksOWQAA7DHJ


Dumpster dive time BABY
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
52,951
16,415
I'm just not sold on Nootbaar. He crushed July and August, like MVP levels of crushing, and every other month he sucked. No shot would I bank on him as an everyday starter. Feels like we'd just be setting up for another lotto ticket in the outfield where, he could be a starter and he could be something that shouldn't even be in the majors.

Jansen for Nootbaar does make a lot of sense for both clubs, they even had pretty similar splits last season in terms of crushing at some months and bad in others.
 
Last edited:
  • Like
Reactions: BrokenFace

Allens Five Hole

Registered User
Jan 17, 2017
234
235
Really do not like those words from Mo. If we are going to spend assets to acquire Murphy, then we need to also be willing to spend money on real talent in our OF (and SP for that matter). Expecting Nootbaar to be an above average OF for 162 games is pretty foolish. Then, after that we have Carlson who I like and TON who could be great again or could be a total bust/hurt half the season.

The Central is going to be really bad again and we seemingly have a pretty clear path to another playoff berth but the way Mo is talking, it'll likely be another 3 game series and out unless Walker and/or Burleson hit the ground sprinting.
 

bleedblue1223

Registered User
Jan 21, 2011
52,951
16,415
Really do not like those words from Mo. If we are going to spend assets to acquire Murphy, then we need to also be willing to spend money on real talent in our OF (and SP for that matter). Expecting Nootbaar to be an above average OF for 162 games is pretty foolish. Then, after that we have Carlson who I like and TON who could be great again or could be a total bust/hurt half the season.

The Central is going to be really bad again and we seemingly have a pretty clear path to another playoff berth but the way Mo is talking, it'll likely be another 3 game series and out unless Walker and/or Burleson hit the ground sprinting.
He also made comments like that before Arenado and Goldy deals, if I recall correctly. I just don't even bother in reading what he says, at this point. It's not like Army, where Army won't show his cards, but he'll also be honest and insightful when he speaks. Mo just sort of says the same thing, very predictable.
 

Allens Five Hole

Registered User
Jan 17, 2017
234
235
He also made comments like that before Arenado and Goldy deals, if I recall correctly. I just don't even bother in reading what he says, at this point. It's not like Army, where Army won't show his cards, but he'll also be honest and insightful when he speaks. Mo just sort of says the same thing, very predictable.
Yeah, he seems like quite an unlikeable chap to be totally honest. I don't have the hate-on most Cards fans do for him but he doesn't exactly brighten up the room.

I'll reserve full judgment on how I think next season will go until Opening Day but right now, just taking his words at face value, it seems like we're okay being that 90 win team that gets a 3 seed and plays roulette with a Wild Card team like we did this year. And that scares me because we do not have the horses in our rotation that others (like the Phils did) do to carry us through a short series.
 

Linkens Mastery

Conductor of the TankTown Express
Jan 15, 2014
20,392
18,108
Hyrule
Probably an unpopular option. But, if they don't get a big guy in free agency, I'm perfectly fine with Edman being our everyday Shortstop.

As long as Gorman/Yepez are relegated to DH and Donavan is our 2B.

Donavan has great OBP and good defensively (just won a GG in his Rookie year) Edman needs to bring more at the Plate but is superb defensively.

We need much more from the OF than we got last year. O'Neill, Carlson, and Nootbaar combined for just two more home runs last year than O'Neill hit by himself the year before.

Also get a elite catcher and a better bullpen.
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad