If Oshawa doesn’t pay it, someone else will. They traded their ‘07 1st round pick to acquire him and McCue. McCue wasn’t the key player in that deal from my perspective. They will want more than they receive din the Guindon trade and I think they will get it from some other team. If Oshawa isn’t willing to go there, move on to other options.
This isn’t about me saying Oshawa will trade D’Amato and picks. It is me saying that is the value they would need to trade to get him if they want him.
Personally, I agree with you. I think Punnet is a better player last season and far more versatile than Smith this year. I was shocked when OS gave up what they did to acquire him and McCue. Shocked.
I like Wakely for Oshawa. You need a 2nd centre behind Ritchie. Line up Senneke and Roobroeck on separate lines with Ritchie and Wakely and it is game over in my opinion. I like Brampton but if Oshawa returns Roobroeck and adds Wakely, with that defence and goaltending plus the experience from a trip to the Finals last year? IMO, that puts Oshawa in the drivers seat. Then just add some depth pieces to fill some of the gaps. Game over.
Some team might be dumb enough/desperate enough to overpay for Konnor Smith, but it most definitely won’t be Oshawa. Especially if Roobroeck returns.
Unless it’s an absolute superstar, the majority of OA players are relatively cheap to acquire. Last year Oshawa gave up a 3rd and a 6th to upgrade from Tommy Stewart to Connor Punnett. That’s a massive improvement.
Giving up D’Amato to acquire Konnor Smith would be a DOWNGRADE for Oshawa. Even if it was a straight up 1-for-1 deal. D’Amato can be trusted for 23min to 25min a game - - as we saw during the Grnerals deep playoff run last year - - and anchors the top power play unit. Konnor Smith can do neither of those.
As it stands now Oshawa has Oster and D’Amato locked into OA spots. If Roobroeck returns, he’ll be the third OA with Torrance being the odd man out.
Paying the price to acquire Wakely makes ZERO sense if Roobroeck returns because of the opportunity cost of losing D’Amato on the blue line. If Roobroeck doesn’t return, then it might be justifiable.
Even though 19yr olds will cost more in a trade than a comparative OA, that’s the direction Oshawa should focus. With Roobroeck returning, Oshawa has the best OA group in the league, bar none. So it would make sense to augment those three with a decent 19yr old.
A guy like Brad Gardiner would be a good option for that. He was a massive disappointment last year, but he could slot in as a serviceable middle six forward. Hard er would be cheaper than Wakely and a much better idea for Oshawa.