I’m trying to watch the Ducks game to see how Gibson plays . The guy looks like he checks out when they start playing crappy . Maybe a rivalry game motivates him …
He's very weird.
He's not showing up with a high percentage of goals stoppable in any of these last 3 years. He (along with Cal Petersen in LA) have a ridiculously low percentage of goals that I've counted stoppable this year to go along with their ridiculously low (but not Devils goalie low) save percentages.
When analyzing Gibson, I do see things in his game where I think ''Yeah, looks like he has no chance on that goal, but I can see why he probably does'', but I don't factor this into my goals stoppable analysis, as this is clearly confirmation bias. When I see a goalie performing poorly in save percentage, but not allowing a very high number of goals stoppable on my count, I do tend to analyze their play, but I separate it from my goals stoppable percentage and I grade everybody the same.
Now one guy that's very weird and sometimes hard to ignore is Jonathan Quick. He doesn't allow A LOT of goals I count stoppable (in some of these years he has though), but you can clearly see goals happen on Quick that he looks like he has no chance on, but due to his style of play, these turn into goals and they're probably not goals on good goalies or even most goalies. He stays down on his ass or belly for a lot of the game. Throws himself out of position terribly (I nailed him on one the other night because it was so f***ing ridiculous how out of position he was and he got scored on from behind the net on a lucky, fluky play, but his inability to get back into proper position was horrendous) and constantly does this and it leads to many unnecessary goal mouth scrambles and eventually goals on some of them.
Scott Wedgewood is another one that sometimes has this questionable way of playing and flopping and throwing himself out of position and making goals that are probably stoppable look like they're not stoppable. I separate this when doing my goals against reviews and percentages tallying, but it is something I notice.