Yeah, the Leafs probably would be. They have 5 games in hand on Tampa and more points. The Leafs could lose their next 5 in regulation and still be ahead of Tampa and have a better record than the Oilers - that's what you call a cushion.
It's a third of the season and they're below .500 - that's not good. About as good as the Ottawa Senators - who are last in the Eastern Conference.
The Oilers are lucky they play in the West, as they would be fighting for last in the East right now. Instead, they get to compete with Arizona and Nashville for a wildcard spot.
Let's relax with the Oilers 'bad luck', they just sucked. The teams around them have actual injuries - the Oilers 'bad luck' is their bad goaltenders are not on a hot streak - doesn't sound like bad luck to me. In comparison, the Leafs were missing three defencemen, and both NHL goalies last game and now their starting goalie is out week to week.. and they still have 30 points in 23 games - that's bad luck. Bad luck isn't having your goalie who was pulled nearly every game last playoffs not be a star.