Proposal: NYR - SJ again

[Lindberg Cheese]

Point to literally any single trade Mike Grier has made where he sent out valuable prospects/desired roster players and got nothing but a cap dump in return

I'll wait. . .

if you look at transactions, the Goodrow one comes to mind as not a good move

 

[TheBeard]

if you look at transactions, the Goodrow one comes to mind as not a good move

He’s probably been one of the team’s three best forwards.

 

[weastern bias]

if you look at transactions, the Goodrow one comes to mind as not a good move

Not what I asked, try again

 

[Lindberg Cheese]

Not what I asked, try again

I corrected your narrow scope.

Tell me how the Goodrow transaction was a good one, I’ll wait

He’s probably been one of the team’s three best forwards.

Great but an attached 2nd rounder would have been nice

 

[MisterT]

50/50, We just have to dangle Trouba and Lindgren in front of Grier, talk a good word salad on intangibles, leadership, winning culture and we’ll come away with Walman and Bystedt.

It's damn tough to out dumb a thread with the Rangers known V. I. actively involved but well done with this nonsense.

 

[weastern bias]

I corrected your narrow scope.

Tell me how the Goodrow transaction was a good one, I’ll wait

I asked a very specific question that addressed your specific hypothetical that you can pry valuable assets out of Grier by referencing the grit and leadership your cap dumps provide

Your rebuttal is the time he claimed a player off waivers for free and spent zero assets to do so, it's an absolute non-sequitor

The Goodrow claim is controversial amongst Sharks fans, though I've always been in favor and he's shown why through 9 games, he's the best forechecker and penalty killer on our team and we got him for nothing but cap space, something the Sharks have in abundance, it made sense to add a player like him to this roster and we didn't spend a single asset to do so

So I will ask again:

Point to literally any single trade Mike Grier has made where he sent out valuable prospects/desired roster players and got nothing but a cap dump in return

I'll wait. . .

 

[Lindberg Cheese]

It's damn tough to out dumb a thread with the Rangers known V. I. actively involved but well done with this nonsense.

Just having a laugh with a far fetched post, there’s a lot of sensitivity around here. Everyone calm down, I’ll exit the safe space now.

 

[weastern bias]

Just having a laugh with a far fetched post, there’s a lot of sensitivity around here. Everyone calm down, I’ll exit the safe space now.

Translation:

I've got nothing

 

[TheBeard]

I corrected your narrow scope.

Tell me how the Goodrow transaction was a good one, I’ll wait


Great but an attached 2nd rounder would have been nice

Sharks have and will have trouble attracting free agents without an unnecessary overpay. Goodrow also had a NTC. San Jose took a free player that otherwise would not have been available. I mean 5 firsts would have been nice too but sharks ultimately got a free forward that’s been solid.

 

[OversKy]

Charlie Lindgren for a first you've convinced me /s

 

[Patty Ice]

if you look at transactions, the Goodrow one comes to mind as not a good move

Aside not to being trade, at worst you could call the Goodrow pickup a superfluous move. He is an effective bottom 6 winger.