World Cup: National Team threads #2

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Blabla bla, nonsense talk as usual.
Talking about the 70 year old colonial past to excuse federations from putting pressure on families of 14 year old in the form of quick money is astonishingly absurd.

Then again....
 

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
Blabla bla, nonsense talk as usual.
Talking about the 70 year old colonial past to excuse federations from putting pressure on families of 14 year old in the form of quick money is astonishingly absurd.

Then again....

Oh, the horror! Receiving perks for my talents! :laugh:

If at least I thought you were honest as opposed to just crying because France can't hoard every single player.
 

TheMoreYouKnow

Registered User
May 3, 2007
16,962
3,941
38° N 77° W
There's a massive difference between coaching a club and a national team.
System managers like Klopp really don't work in national teams, there's just no time to implement the system, nor can you buy specific players to thrive in it.

A national team managers needs to do 3 things:
- basic system and good in-game management
- be great at man management and motivation
- create basically a cult around the national team

If you don't have the players to do a 4-3-3 high press, but a counter-attacking 3-5-2, you do that.

etc etc

TLDR; Klopp comparison is off the mark IMO.
I disagree on Klopp. His system isn't that complex (it's in fact much simpler than what Germany has been trying to play). His success comes from his communicative and motivational ability not from intricate tactics. It's definitely doable for a national team, but in any event that was just one example.

I could have just said - look how far Croatia got in tournaments with a squad full of questionable guys and just a couple of elite players. And if you take offense to that, I could also refer to Germany's 2014 squad - which had plenty of holes that people could have pointed at to explain an early exit if, say, that Algeria match is actually lost. Some of that is luck, but some of it is also down to creating a successful team where guys know what their role is and execute it, where guys go the extra mile and so forth.

But of course such a team is a fragile thing and doesn't last forever. Jogi's downfall was that he continued to operate on assumptions that worked when he had Lahm and Schweinsteiger and prime Hummels/Boateng at the back. And Flick to some extent continued chasing that mirage. That doesn't mean that's the only way Germany could play, it's just the way those guys knew. And when there's a disconnect between what managers say and demand and the reality on the pitch, players eventually stop listening and stop taking instructions seriously. Flick ultimately failed because he couldn't adjust tactics to personnel and as a result the personnel stopped taking him seriously. The new manager's first task is to restore the players' confidence in the team's leadership.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
  • Haha
Reactions: Spring in Fialta

cgf

FireBednarsSuccessor
Oct 15, 2010
61,488
19,731
w/ Renly's Peach
As I told you before the WC, during the WC and since the WC, your defense is in shambles and you can't win much with a guy like Sule as starter.
Italy had a midfield Germany can't match. And were solid at the back.
Germany only has talented forwards and wingers. And even them have trouble being efficient.

I said this : "Italy had a midfield Germany can't match".
So yeah, you're moving the goalposts AGAIN.

No he won't help his reputation reaching a QF with Germany. Not a top coach job.
Only if he reaches a final does he prove he's one of the best coaches in the business.
IMO he has everything to lose by joining them.

Mind you, you expected Flick to change everything after Jogi and lead them to glory. Turns out he made them worse. He, too, hurt his reputation after his glorious Bayern job.

You should read your own posts if you expect anyone else to :dunno:


I was optimistic about Flick initially because I watched the team play, it was radically different than we played under Jogi. It's just gone to s*** since Qatar and he's been unable to right the ship.
 

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC

Receiving perks.... Hahaha, the laughable argument...
And the link above should educate you on the Benzema case that you apparently know nothing about except right wing shit.

LOL, from the article:


Les citations déformées de Karim Benzema sur l’équipe de France et l’Algérie


Luis Fernandez : « Karim, alors, la sélection algérienne, est-ce que pour toi c’est possible ou c’est plus possible la sélection française… »


Karim Benzema : « Ben… Non… Tout à l’heure j’ai eu une discussion avec le président [et] l’entraîneur, on a bien parlé maintenant moi je dis l’Algérie, voilà… C’est le pays de mes parents, c’est dans le cœur. Mais bon après sportivement, c’est vrai que je jouerai en équipe de France. Je serai là toujours présent pour l’équipe de France. »


Luis Fernandez : « Si j’ai bien compris t’as fait un choix, ton choix à toi se porte sur l’équipe de France. »


Karim Benzema : « Ouais voilà. »


Luis Fernandez : « C’est pas l’Algérie... »


Karim Benzema : « Non. »


Florian Genton: « A un moment donné vous vous êtes posé la question quand même Karim ou directement vous vous êtes dit c’est l’équipe de France pour le côté sportif ? »


Karim Benzema : « Ben… C’est plus pour le côté sportif, parce que l’Algérie c’est mon pays, voilà, mes parents ils viennent de là-bas. Après, la France… C’est plus sportif, voilà. »

And are you denying that he refused to sing the national anthem?

Oh, and another gem from Benzema:

Dans une interview à So Foot en décembre 2011, le footballeur jugeait que les supporteurs français sont « dans un délire bizarre. En gros, si je marque, je suis français, mais si je ne marque pas ou qu’il y a des problèmes, je suis arabe. »
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Did you read the article AT ALL? Do you really understand french?

You're really doing exactly as the article says : right wing extremists taking phrases left and right and cutting the parts they don't want to read.
Hilarious !
 

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
Did you read the article AT ALL? Do you really understand french?

Are you serious?

In the article, Benzema says that Algeria is his country and in his heart and that France is more for the sporting side. Furthermore, he goes on to say that when he scores he's French but when there's a problem, he's Arab.

Does that sound like someone who played for France out of national pride? Christ, how oblivious can you be?
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Are you serious?

In the article, Benzema says that Algeria is his country and in his heart and that France is more for the sporting side. Furthermore, he goes on to say that when he scores he's French but when there's a problem, he's Arab.

Does that sound like someone who played for France out of national pride? Christ, how oblivious can you be?
Yup, right wing extremist bias.
Incredible.

You're now the Mme Le Pen of this board.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Just to help :
L’histoire retient moins qu’il a aussi dit : « C’est un rêve pour moi de jouer pour l’équipe de France », qu’il raconte à l’envi que c’est dans la région de Lyon (à Bron, où il a grandi) qu’il se sent le mieux, ou encore qu’il affirme que ne pas avoir été sélectionné en équipe de France pour l’Euro 2016 a été le plus gros coup dur de sa carrière.

French is a tough langage I know. Not easy for some.

Me right-wing? :laugh:

Either refute what I'm saying with actual facts or be quiet.
You're literaly doing EXACTLY what they're doing : taking only the parts you want and not bringing the others.
Sorry Mme Le Pen, people aren't idiots. They can actually read.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Jersey Fresh

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
Just to help :
L’histoire retient moins qu’il a aussi dit : « C’est un rêve pour moi de jouer pour l’équipe de France », qu’il raconte à l’envi que c’est dans la région de Lyon (à Bron, où il a grandi) qu’il se sent le mieux, ou encore qu’il affirme que ne pas avoir été sélectionné en équipe de France pour l’Euro 2016 a été le plus gros coup dur de sa carrière.

French is a tough langage I know. Not easy for some.

Yeah, so he's talked out of both sides of his mouth.

I know what I believe in when a guy refuses to sing the national anthem and calls France racist every five seconds (which he's right).

And we both know what Euro 16 was about. Valbuena.
 

cgf

FireBednarsSuccessor
Oct 15, 2010
61,488
19,731
w/ Renly's Peach
It's not about any particular players in defense as much as it is about not committing to any particular players in defense. Süle has played this one match after the World Cup. Wasn't very good at either to be sure, but also not why the team has been performing awfully as a whole. He and many others can be useful complementary pieces when the team as a whole functions coherently, but that will never happen with a pack of strangers where everyone does their thing and in the end nothing works.

Yeah. There was a lot of experimenting to be done since 2016 that only started happening 2 years ago, so there's little stability or cohesion.

A lot of the things Flick tried out where interesting ideas on paper and worth testing, but they were not going to be successful without giving them time, or building them on top of a pre-existing cohesion that we just have had since 2014-2016.

Whoever takes over needs to start to establish a consistent group defensively and let them settle in together...and it can't include Süle & Rüdiger. Both are just too high-event defenders to pair together, even if surrounded by a more traditional 6 + defensive FBs.

Part of me wants to replace both of them and just live with whatever growing pains a Schlotterbeck - Thiaw partnership has to go through...and start integrating Martel at the 6. Although if it's Nagelsmann that gets the job, I'd give Süle another go, as JN seems to know how to get the most out of big Nik.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
I know what I believe in when a guy refuses to sing the national anthem and calls France racist every five seconds (which he's right).
Almost nobody sang the anthem in 84. Platini didn't feel french?
And 2016 wasn't about Valbuena. It was about Benz acting like shit and getting what he deserved. Had nothing to do with origin or race (though for sure the right wing extremists loved it, using your own words of this thread).
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Spring in Fialta

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
You should read your own posts if you expect anyone else to :dunno:


I was optimistic about Flick initially because I watched the team play, it was radically different than we played under Jogi. It's just gone to s*** since Qatar and he's been unable to right the ship.
Yes, quite clearly as "their strength is".

Are we talking about Benzema or Platini?

Nice deflection bubs
"I know what I believe in when a guy refuses to sing the national anthem"
So you know what to believe.
 

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
@Evilo How the f*** wasn't 2016 not about Valbuena but him acting like shit when the biggest scandal was him blackmailing Valbuena with a sex tape? (Mind you, I don't think it was racism either. Benzema fully deserved to be kicked off the team)
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
@Evilo How the f*** wasn't 2016 not about Valbuena but him acting like shit when the biggest scandal was him blackmailing Valbuena with a sex tape? (Mind you, I don't think it was racism either. Benzema fully deserved to be kicked off the team)
I meant it wasn't Valbuena who was the reason. It was Benzema's own doing.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Yes, I know what I believe in when seeing Benzema's actions and the majority of his words. It's not just one thing bubs.
Majority?
Nope. The ONLY things Benzema said for his ENTIRE career that were negative, mostly when he was angry at not being selected for his own wrongdoings, are in the article.
Ignoring the VAST majority of Benzema saying he felt french, saying he loved France, saying he learnt his football in France, saying he was proud of playing for France, that it was his childhood dream, etc...

That's exactly far right talk.
 

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
Ben
Majority?
Nope. The ONLY things Benzema said for his ENTIRE career that were negative, mostly when he was angry at not being selected for his own wrongdoings, are in the article.
Ignoring the VAST majority of Benzema saying he felt french, saying he loved France, saying he learnt his football in France, saying he was proud of playing for France, that it was his childhood dream, etc...

That's exactly far right talk.


Florian Genton: « A un moment donné vous vous êtes posé la question quand même Karim ou directement vous vous êtes dit c’est l’équipe de France pour le côté sportif ? »


Karim Benzema : « Ben… C’est plus pour le côté sportif, parce que l’Algérie c’est mon pays, voilà, mes parents ils viennent de là-bas. Après, la France… C’est plus sportif, voilà. »

He was angry there too? Before anything ever happened? :laugh:

I think you must genuinely be the only guy on the planet that thinks Benzema picked France out of national pride. Man, never change. The amount of blacks and maghrebins who must snicker behind your back.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Ben



Florian Genton: « A un moment donné vous vous êtes posé la question quand même Karim ou directement vous vous êtes dit c’est l’équipe de France pour le côté sportif ? »


Karim Benzema : « Ben… C’est plus pour le côté sportif, parce que l’Algérie c’est mon pays, voilà, mes parents ils viennent de là-bas. Après, la France… C’est plus sportif, voilà. »

He was angry there too? Before anything ever happened? :laugh:

I think you must genuinely be the only guy on the planet that thinks Benzema picked France out of national pride. Man, never change. The amount of blacks and maghrebins who must snicker behind your back.
He literally said so Mme Le Pen.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Spring in Fialta

Spring in Fialta

A malign star kept him
Apr 1, 2007
27,330
16,115
Montreal, QC
He literally said so Mme Le Pen.

Yo Evilo, I can also tell you that I like you. Doesn't mean it's true. :laugh:

Even when confronted about the national anthem, all he said was that him singing wouldn't make him score a hat-trick, that he liked the team and that it was a dream to play for the French team only to end it with 'no one is going to force me to sing La Marseillaise'

By the way, I have no issue with whether he sings or not. It's his business. But come on man, to think it's not telling with everything else he's said and done, what a joke.
 

Evilo

Registered User
Mar 17, 2002
63,588
9,455
France
Yo Evilo, I can also tell you that I like you. Doesn't mean it's true. :laugh:

Even when confronted about the national anthem, all he said was that him singing wouldn't make him score a hat-trick, that he liked the team and that it was a dream to play for the French team only to end it with 'no one is going to force me to sing La Marseillaise'

By the way, I have no issue with whether he sings or not. It's his business. But come on man, to think it's not telling with everything else he's said and done, what a joke.
So when he says one thing it's true, when he says another it's not but YOU decide when it is when it fits your far right agenda.

And no, most players don't sing the anthem and I couldn't care any less.
 

Wee Baby Seamus

Yo, Goober, where's the meat?
Mar 15, 2011
16,264
7,334
Halifax/Toronto
The mental gymnastics required to transmogrify “the colonial power shouldn’t get to pick and choose the identity and national affiliation of the colonized” into somehow a right wing position is genuinely remarkable
 
  • Like
Reactions: bluesfan94

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad