Mark Hunter opens up about the debates about who to select with the No. 4 pick at the 2015 NHL Draft.
theathletic.com
The debate wasn’t really about Mitch Marner.
Discussions about what the Maple Leafs should do with the No. 4 pick in the 2015 NHL Draft were more philosophical in nature, according to Mark Hunter, who oversaw the draft then as the team’s director of player personnel.
Namely, should the Leafs, in the earliest stages of a rebuild, pick another forward, or try to land a potential stud on defence?
“It was more debate about position,” Hunter told The Athletic. “Everybody liked Mitch.”
It’s been seven years since the Leafs ultimately went with Marner from the London Knights. Now 25, Marner was recently named the NHL’s top right winger for the second year in a row, becoming the first Maple Leaf since Tim Horton in the late 1960s to earn a first-team All-Star nod in back-to-back seasons.
The Leafs would look a lot different right now had Hunter not gotten his way and gone with Marner. At least one very powerful voice in the organization believed they needed to at least consider a foundational piece on the back end with the pick.
“I don’t want to throw (Mike) Babcock under the bus. I have no beef with him at all,” Hunter says of Babcock, who had signed an eight-year contract to become the Leafs head coach five weeks before the 2015 draft. “But he was just saying, if there was a star defenceman there (at No. 4), we really gotta consider taking that star defenceman instead of a forward.”
It wasn’t an unreasonable thought.
................
The Leafs discussed Noah Hanifin and Ivan Provorov, Babcock recalled in an email to The Athletic. But in the end, Hunter knew best, Babcock said. He’d seen everyone, knew Marner’s “drive train” and skill set and ultimately made a “great call.”
Hunter knew Marner better than just about anyone else. He was the Knights’ general manager – and part of the ownership group – when the club selected Marner with the 19th pick at the 2013 OHL draft. He witnessed Marner’s impressive rookie year in London (59 points in 64 games) not long before he joined the Leafs’ management team in 2014. Everyone could see the skill. Hunter knew better than most how Marner was built. He knew his makeup.