So, once again, you're arguing in circles just be the board contrarian.
Contrarian? This all started because I agreed with another poster. It isn't my fault that every time I post something people want to argue with me. No one argued with the guy that posted before me that a #1 doesn't guarantee you anything.
Law school certainly helped you deflect and redirect your conversations.
I picked an item in your list that you inferred was good to have but was not necessarily needed to win a Cup (being good defensively).
I made the claim that you do, in fact, need to be good defensively to win a Cup. It's not nice to have; it's a must.
Somehow we're now talking about needing a good offense, which I would throw a giant 'Captain Obvious' sticker on. Good defensive teams sometimes miss the playoffs because they can't score enough goals. Rarely do good offensive teams miss the playoffs because goals can carry you through a regular season; however, teams that are only good offensively don't win the Cup because they have to play too many teams with good defensive hockey to get there in the playoffs.
Again, nice redirect.
Redirect? I responded directly to your post. I said that you obviously would like to have the best everything, but if you have enough X to compensate for Y, you can still win. You then said you can't win without a good defense. My response is that you can't win without a good offense, which is also true. I've also said (maybe not necessarily in response to you, but in the same thread on the same topic), that you need a lot more than just the good offense/defense/goalie/coach/whatever. You're obviously not going to win with a defense like the Flyers have right now. I'm not arguing that you can win with a ****** defense or a ****** team. What I am saying, however, is the same thing I have been saying throughout this thread...that you can win if you have enough of X (scoring, coaching, defense, goaltending) to compensate for a lack of Y (scoring, coaching, defense, goaltending). If you are scoring at a ridiculous pace, your defense doesn't have to be the best in the league. If your defense is the best in the league, your offense doesn't have to score at a ridiculous pace.
I guess I should have just said, "You are right" after you posted. Oops. Redirect!