Proposal: Mcdavid to Toronto

[Moose and Squirrel]

Like? One example...

NYR have some good young prospects and picks that would be appealing.. LA as well

 

[Hockey 4 Life]

I normally never believe home town Boys will come back home to be a leaf when they hit ufa, but I truly believe McDavid will in this case. Its just a feeling and I could totally be wrong of course. Just a gut feeling.

 

[Marner4Life]

McDavid, Hyman and Kassian for
Mathews, Nylander, Kerfoot

McDavid>Mathews
Nylander>Hyman
Kerfoot>Kassian
$$$ are close
Leafs get tougher to play against Oilers get more balanced scoring!

 

[Riseonfire]

Ah yes, this solves Toronto's long standing problem of too much defense and not enough offense.

 

[A1LeafNation]

NYR have some good young prospects and picks that would be appealing.. LA as well

Like I said Leafs are the only team here that can trade 100 point 23 year old. They aren't selling hope.

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

Like I said Leafs are the only team here that can trade 100 point 23 year old. They aren't selling hope.

if you're trading McDavid, it's for high end prospects and picks

a package around Marner, an injured goalie and low end picks ain't it, IMO

 

[sens13]

Like I said Leafs are the only team here that can trade 100 point 23 year old. They aren't selling hope.

who's the 100 point 23 year old? marner has hit 90 once like 3 years. Calling him perennial 100 point scorer is just showing your bias.

Not to mention if oilers were to trade mcdavid they will be looking for high end prospects.
Not heavily overpaid soft wingers.

 

[A1LeafNation]

if you're trading McDavid, it's for high end prospects and picks

a package around Marner, an injured goalie and low end picks ain't it, IMO

Really with Draisaitl and Nurse locked up, they are rebuilding?

 

[YP44]

This does nothing to address Edmonton's D or Goaltending (Mrazek is not the answer IMO).

If Edmonton is moving one of their two studs it should be Leon in a deal for a quality D and Goalie. Like Hart, Provorov, Laughten. even then if I am Holland I do a better job building around Leon and McDavid.

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

Really with Draisaitl and Nurse locked up, they are rebuilding?

how does a lesser winger for a top end Center address EDM's needs?

 

[Eternal Leaf]

I assume the Oilers would be rebuilding if McDavid is out.

Marner
Sandin/Liljegren
Robertson
2022 1st
2023 1st

So that's essentially a young star + 1 blue-chip prospect + 1 good prospect + two 1st rounders (three considering one of Sandin and Lily would be a first-rounder too). They could add a few smaller pieces (i.e. 2nds, prospects) but there's no reason to include that here.

Marner would be a good safety net to protect against a prospect not working out. It's a good haul.

I don't know if that would be the best deal available though. I think another team could outdo it with higher quality prospects even if they don't give a star like Marner.

 

[A1LeafNation]

if you're trading McDavid, it's for high end prospects and picks

a package around Marner, an injured goalie and low end picks ain't it, IMO

You right 90 point player.

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

This does nothing to address Edmonton's D or Goaltending (Mrazek is not the answer IMO).

If Edmonton is moving one of their two studs it should be Leon in a deal for a quality D and Goalie. Like Hart, Provorov, Laughten. even then if I am Holland I do a better job building around Leon and McDavid.

agreed, that trade does nothing for EDM, but maybe make them worse.. and does the cap even work?

 

[A1LeafNation]

how does a lesser winger for a top end Center address EDM's needs?

It's the best they can get for a disgruntped player.

Is that the premise of the trade McDavid proposals lol

 

[TopT]

This is an absurd proposal.

McDavid is not going anywhere.

If he were going to the Leafs -- which he is not -- Matthews would have to go the other way. Neither team does that.

Toronto most certainly does

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

You right 90 point player.

think along the line another poster put in for a PHI trade

EDM trade for Marner minus McDavid actually is a loss, not a gain..

 

[A1LeafNation]

think along the line another poster put in for a PHI trade

EDM trade for Marner minus McDavid actually is a loss, not a gain..

Everyone knows this lol.

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

It's the best they can get for a disgruntped player.

Is that the premise of the trade McDavid proposals lol

bet it's not the best they can get....

 

[AvatarAang]

Can we just ban all McDavid proposals, Oiler fans have suffered enough.

 

[rocketdan9]

To Leafs: Connor Mcdavid

To Oilers: Mitch Marner
Petr Mrazek
Nick Robertson
1st round pick 2022
1st round pick 2023

You high sir?

It would have to include AM34. No matter which way you slice it

 

[sens13]

It's the best they can get for a disgruntped player.

Is that the premise of the trade McDavid proposals lol

How do you know that's the best?

If mcdavid is available other teams will make their star players available. pastrnak and rantanen are 2 players that come to mind that are both better and cheaper than marner. And there are lots of other options too.

You think oilers are rushing to take the heaviley overpaid soft winger? Get real

So edm will take the winger that 90% of your fanbase doesn't even want because it's the best offer and your sure about that? Do you even read what you write?

 

[A1LeafNation]

You high sir?

It would have to include AM34. No matter which way you slice it

No it doesn't. Lol.

 

[Smartguy]

NYR have some good young prospects and picks that would be appealing.. LA as well

NYR and LA I think are the only 2 teams in the league who could put together a proposal that people wouldn’t scoff at. They’d have to gut their team to do it, which is why he will never be traded, not to mention the Oilers owner would never sign it off

 

[sens13]

No it doesn't. Lol.

Said by a true homer.

 

[rocketdan9]

No it doesn't. Lol.

For that package then... Edm hangs up the phone and burns it