Proposal: Mcdavid to Toronto

[DangleBojangle]

To Leafs: Connor Mcdavid

To Oilers: Mitch Marner
Petr Mrazek
Nick Robertson
1st round pick 2022
1st round pick 2023

Click to read more...

 

[Ragdoll]

Nope, try again. Absolutely brutal.

 

[jrs]

Oh no

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

To Leafs: Connor Mcdavid

To Oilers: Mitch Marner
Petr Mrazek
Nick Robertson
1st round pick 2022
1st round pick 2023

so... a good player, a prospect, and injury prone goalie (with 2 more yrs @3.8m no less.. basically cap dump) and 2 late-ish 1sts... don't see it

 

[ottomaddox]

McDavid might not enjoy playing 3rd line center on TOR.

 

[DangleBojangle]

so... a good player, a prospect, and injury prone goalie (with 2 more yrs @3.8m no less.. basically cap dump) and 2 late-ish 1sts... don't see it

Mrazek>Koskinen

 

[A1LeafNation]

Who is the closest example we can use?

Don't think any teams will be able to add a 23 year old 100 point player like the Leafs can.

 

[GreeningOil]

McDavid might not enjoy playing 3rd line center on TOR.

Matthews/ McDaddy would be on line #1. Don’t be a silly goose

 

[ottomaddox]

so... a good player, a prospect, and injury prone goalie (with 2 more yrs @3.8m no less.. basically cap dump) and 2 late-ish 1sts... don't see it

Stanley Cup ?

 

[GreeningOil]

Who is the closest example we can use?

Don't think any teams will be able to add a 23 year old 100 point player like the Leafs can.

Except they can’t add that. Edmonton isn’t giving you McDavid

 

[Ciao]

This is an absurd proposal.

McDavid is not going anywhere.

If he were going to the Leafs -- which he is not -- Matthews would have to go the other way. Neither team does that.

 

[Sweetpotato]

Toronto doesn't have the pieces however much it'd be cool to see him and Matthews play again.

 

[SeanMoneyHands]

Nick Robertson seals this deal.

 

[Ciao]

Toronto doesn't have the pieces however much it'd be cool to see him and Matthews play again.

No can do

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

Stanley Cup ?

1st round exits are usually in the 20's

 

[Moose and Squirrel]

Mrazek>Koskinen

oh well, put it like that, fax it in!

 

[CycloneSweep]

This is an absurd proposal.

McDavid is not going anywhere.

If he were going to the Leafs -- which he is not -- Matthews would have to go the other way. Neither team does that.

Pretty much.

 

[A1LeafNation]

McDavid might not enjoy playing 3rd line center on TOR.

Tavares Matthews Amirov
Bunting McDavid Nylander
Mikheyev Kampf Kase
Engvall Spezza Simmonds

 

[BigBadBruins7708]

Matthews for RNH and 2 1sts....

 

[bert]

This is an absurd proposal.

McDavid is not going anywhere.

If he were going to the Leafs -- which he is not -- Matthews would have to go the other way. Neither team does that.

Uhhh.... Even if they were equal which they are not. Mcdavid has a way better contract. Would have to be a significant add from Toronto to get this done.

 

[sens13]

Who is the closest example we can use?

Don't think any teams will be able to add a 23 year old 100 point player like the Leafs can.

any team will give up a ton if mcdavid available. Stop acting like the leafs are so amazing only they can add him.

And marner is so overrated by you guys. He's a soft heavily overpaid winger who can't do shit by himself

 

[GoLeafsGo96]

This is an absurd proposal.

McDavid is not going anywhere.

If he were going to the Leafs -- which he is not -- Matthews would have to go the other way. Neither team does that.

I actually don't agree with it having to be Matthews. It legitimately wouldn't even make sense for the Oilers to go after Matthews because its safe to assume Matthews would walk as a UFA from the Oilers sans McDavid. If the Oilers are trading McDavid - they're blowing it the hell up for multiple years.

McDavid won't get traded unless he absolutely demands it and things get ugly. If he did, other teams would be a much better fit than Toronto - so it would require him demanding to go to Toronto.

A world where McDavid demands to go to the Leafs would require obscene dominoes where the Leafs trade Marner to someone else (or the Oilers if they wanted him, but again for similar reasons to Matthews I expect they wouldn't) and then its just a ridiculous amount of picks, prospects, and RFA team controlled young options.

So yeah, not happening.

 

[A1LeafNation]

any team will give up a ton if mcdavid available. Stop acting like leafs are so amazing only they can add him.
And marner is so overrated by you guys. He's a soft heavily overpaid winger who can't do shit by himself

Like? One example...

 

[sens13]

How about marner/1st/sandin? A very good mod said this was totally fair

Didn't know hf let any good off the street be a mod

 

[sens13]

Like? One example...

Go through any team. Add in a star player, good prospects, picks. Not hard

What makes the leafs so special that only they can trade for mcdavid?