Player Discussion Marner

Mr_Fun

FFS!
Oct 7, 2006
4,377
4,066
BC
Yeah, not a good read with half the net showing; I won't argue that. He did hit a one timer earlier on so there's that.

Maybe a phantom assist on the 1st goal as the best I can see (on my phone) is he redirected a puck to AM. At very least though, it was a good read to see that AM had a lane to the net and he let him have the puck. He also found AM in the slot earlier for a sitter than AM uncharacteristically duffed.

Pretty good bounce back game for him as the two before that were hideous by any standard.
 

Racer88

Registered User
Sep 29, 2020
11,914
11,936

Former Leafs Defenseman Blames Mitch Marner for Power Play Struggles​


View attachment 922371

As Carlo Colaiacovo points out, however, with a wide-open cage, Swayman completely out of position, and the defender not in-line to block the shot, Marner opted to pass it off instead of putting the puck in the wide open cage. While he collected 3 assists in the game to give him a team-high 10 points on the year, it's situations like this that drive the city and its fan base nuts.

View attachment 922374
With a struggling power play, simplification is of the utmost importance, but the Leafs seem more content with whipping passes around then firing shots towards the net. With the likes of Marner, Auston Matthews, William Nylander, John Tavares, and Morgan Rielly among others, it's unacceptable to have just 3 power play goals to start the year and 10 goals in their last 35 regular season contests, going back to February 27th.
Holy crap why didn’t he just shoot it into the open net. It’s stuff like that why he isn’t worth his contract let alone a bigger one
 
  • Like
Reactions: LeafSteel

Niagara Bill

Registered User
Oct 11, 2021
1,898
1,387
Because it wasn't as simple as the misleading freeze frame makes it look.
I mean he obviously should have shot it but it was good (imo) that he set up 2 goals* over the course of the rest of the game


*from the blueline
Marner is a talent, without a doubt and if this league did not have a salary cap everyone would want him on the Leafs, but we have a cap, and all fans know that we need Cale Makar type more than Marner type under our system. Even if he just walks, the 10m ìf handled right can enhance this team.
 

Nineteen67

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Dec 12, 2017
24,842
11,584
Marner is a talent, without a doubt and if this league did not have a salary cap everyone would want him on the Leafs, but we have a cap, and all fans know that we need Cale Makar type more than Marner type under our system. Even if he just walks, the 10m ìf handled right can enhance this team.
Signing UFAs with the $10m would be fine if they were a contender and were filling in a couple of pieces. Where the Leafs are, they’d be wasting money and even worse, time.

The best option was to trade him for young assets.
 

ACC1224

Super Elite, Passing ALL Tests since 2002
Aug 19, 2002
76,181
42,485
Man this thread never fails to deliver. Still haven't figured out if people are serious with this stuff, pretty funny at any rate.



1730119540035.png
 

Gallagbi

Formerly Eazy_B97
Jul 5, 2005
49,449
12,020
Marner is a talent, without a doubt and if this league did not have a salary cap everyone would want him on the Leafs, but we have a cap, and all fans know that we need Cale Makar type more than Marner type under our system. Even if he just walks, the 10m ìf handled right can enhance this team.
Feels like there's 1 Makar type in the league and I think the Avs are going to keep him. There's some really great D, not sure you're getting any for Mitch at the moment, but Makar-type is pretty rare
 

Dekes For Days

Registered User
Sep 24, 2018
21,190
15,919
Looked worse live
Live, you can see that the goalie is already moving over, and that side of the net would not all be open.
Live, you can see that the defender is already moving over, and there's a good possibility that they would be able to block the shot (with a player exiting the box).
Live, you can see that they were trying for quick tic tac plays to create movement, which is very common on 5v3s.
Live, you can see that not shooting there results in the best goal scorer in the world getting a teed up unblocked slap shot from the faceoff circle two seconds later.

It's a decent shot opportunity, and maybe he should have shot, but one would think that after all of the times Boston, Tampa, etc. have burned us with the touch pass instead of a shot in a position like that, people would understand that shooting isn't the only option, especially on a 5 on 3. Players make hundreds of split second decisions every game, and we can post misleading freeze frames to criticize every single one we don't like, or dismiss beautiful primary assists creating goals because of the location of the passer (lol), but we all know that Marner was the best Leafs on the ice that night.
Marner is a talent, without a doubt and if this league did not have a salary cap everyone would want him on the Leafs, but we have a cap, and all fans know that we need Cale Makar type more than Marner type under our system.
Not only is that not true, but getting rid of Marner doesn't get you a Makar. It gets you overpaid mid-tier UFAs that provide less impact than Marner.
 
  • Like
Reactions: 02blkvert

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad