Flaw #1: Marian Gaborik has severe technical/range of motion/athleticism limitations. In fact, he might be the least athletic supposedly star player there has ever been.
When do you see Gaborik reach up and grab a puck or reach behind him for a puck and rip a wrister.
Scenario A: You place Marian Gaborik between the dots and glue his skates to the ice. You take a bucket of pucks and dump them in front of him. You tell Gaborik to keep the pucks where they are and just start firing them on net from different release points. Now thats a scary sight. Dude has one release point. Why? Because he's built like a tin man. No flexibility, agility, whatever those fancy terms are. He is limited in all those things.
Flaw # 2: He's as soft as a player can possibly be. I know some people think its cliche to bring up, I know some people say "stop hating Euros", I know some people say its not his job to grind, I know some people say look at him go in front of the net to try to score. Just stop. Marian Gaborik is as soft as any player I've ever witnessed.
Exhibit A: 55 seconds into tonights game, Gaborik is skating gingerly back into the defensive zone and gets tripped up. He hits the ice about 3 feet above the faceoff circle and ends up helping himself up off the ice at the freakin' end boards! My jaw literally dropped when it happened. He just doesn't have an ounce of hockey toughness in him. It has nothing to do with size, style of play, etc.
Please ask if you'd like more analysis. I enjoy sharing my perspective.