Value of: Manson/Rakell/Lindholm

[KaseMeOutside]

Presuming none sign extensions what is the market for these players to contenders.

Lindholm is a great player but is injury prone

Rakell is very talented and is a very good complimentary player who gets hot and cold

Manson has lost a step but is still a physical presence who can help a cup contender as long as they dont expect him to be a top pairing player

Click to read more...

 

[Cancuks]

I'd take Manson in Vancouver. Not willing to offer much unless the Ducks take back Myers.

 

[vatali]

Lindholm will bring you a kings ransom. Probably the first or second most sought after asset at the TDL (depending on Hertl). I would expect a A prospect and a low 1st

 

[KaseMeOutside]

I'd take Manson in Vancouver. Not willing to offer much unless the Ducks take back Myers.

They're better off letting him walk than doing Jim Benning a favor like that

 

[ManofSteel55]

The Oilers would be interested in Manson and/or Rakell, depending on how cap can be worked with and how much the ask is.

 

[SCMURRAY]

Lindholm will be a 1st and prospect/pick. Should be on the Isles radar for sure

 

[elitepete]

Jurmo+2nd for Manson at the deadline

 

[Blanick]

As a Blues fan I would be very interested in Lindholm. I have actually brought him up several times on our boards as a possible target this year to fill out our defense. Likely would need the Ducks to either retain some salary and take back a contract (Scandella) to make it happen though, which of course would drive the price even higher.

 

[gilfaizon]

As a Blues fan I would be very interested in Lindholm. I have actually brought him up several times on our boards as a possible target this year to fill out our defense. Likely would need the Ducks to either retain some salary and take back a contract (Scandella) to make it happen though, which of course would drive the price even higher.

I have a feeling the Ducks will have no issue retaining in order to get bigger pieces for these guys. I suspect they'll try hard to extend at least one if not two of these guys, though.

 

[Geardedandbearded]

Broberg+yammamoto+2022 first+lavoie for lindholm+getzlaf+rakell

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Jurmo+2nd for Manson at the deadline

I like it, I assume 50%

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

Broberg+yammamoto+2022 first+lavoie for lindholm+getzlaf+rakell

Haha really loading up for that playoff run

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

If lindholm isn’t bringing home a really uncomfortable package from the other team, doubt he is moved.


Should resign him ASAP

 

[jcbeze]

combined? Not Jack Eichel

 

[Arthuros]

combined? Not Jack Eichel

Good, I'm tired of hearing about Eichel and how much we'd have to give up to get him.

 

[LTIR]

Broberg+yammamoto+2022 first+lavoie for lindholm+getzlaf+rakell

Salary cap says No.. as does Holland.

All 3 would be rentals because Oilers won't have any cap space to extend any of them

 

[Geardedandbearded]

Salary cap says No.. as does Holland.

All 3 would be rentals because Oilers won't have any cap space to extend any of them

ducks can retain and we can move some salary out; especially if this is closer to the TDL. As far as the second part goes, idc if it brings a cup to Edmonton this year and with that trade I think that would be the case. I’m also more confident in koski than most. Don’t laugh but I think he’s ready to go tukka rask mode

 

[TFHockey]

Broberg+yammamoto+2022 first+lavoie for lindholm+getzlaf+rakell

That trade is dumb on so many levels, even ignoring the impossible cap implications.

For a haul like that (oh and remember, Getzlaf isn't going anywhere) and in any trade with the Ducks the Oilers must target Gibson. Gibson and Lindholm would cost a lot (you're giving up three first round assets plus a great prospect in Lavoie and hardly moving any salary out in your absurd trade) but the Oilers must move Koskinen when getting a goalie from anyone. So there is a lot to unpack there. Hell I don't even think NHL22 would you make that deal.

 

[LTIR]

ducks can retain and we can move some salary out; especially if this is closer to the TDL. As far as the second part goes, idc if it brings a cup to Edmonton this year and with that trade I think that would be the case. I’m also more confident in koski than most. Don’t laugh but I think he’s ready to go tukka rask mode

Koski being good is another reason why this makes no sense. Oilers won't even be able to afford him past this season even if they walked away from Puljujarvi.

Oilers are in cap he'll next season and need guys like Lavoie, Skinner and Broberg to be NHL regulars next season

 

[Geardedandbearded]

Koski being good is another reason why this makes no sense. Oilers won't even be able to afford him past this season even if they walked away from Puljujarvi.

Oilers are in cap he'll next season and need guys like Lavoie, Skinner and Broberg to be NHL regulars next season

If I haven’t made it clear my concern is this season. The cap crunch next year is part of that. Samorukov, Holloway, benson and McLeod will handle the rookie salaries needed for next year. Maybe bourg too.

 

[Geardedandbearded]

That trade is dumb on so many levels, even ignoring the impossible cap implications.

For a haul like that (oh and remember, Getzlaf isn't going anywhere) and in any trade with the Ducks the Oilers must target Gibson. Gibson and Lindholm would cost a lot (you're giving up three first round assets plus a great prospect in Lavoie and hardly moving any salary out in your absurd trade) but the Oilers must move Koskinen when getting a goalie from anyone. So there is a lot to unpack there. Hell I don't even think NHL22 would you make that deal.

I’d argue we don’t need to upgrade goalie this year. However, filling out the roster while not completely mortgaging the future, ahead of a cap crunch next year, means going for the cup this year and with those additions I’d being feeling good about a cup run.

 

[LTIR]

If I haven’t made it clear my concern is this season. The cap crunch next year is part of that. Samorukov, Holloway, benson and McLeod will handle the rookie salaries needed for next year. Maybe bourg too.

There shouldn't be any concern. Oilers will breeze into playoffs with what they have. We don't need to add Rakell or Getzlaf.
Yama struggling this season is good for EDM long term. We might actually be able to get both him and Puljujarvi signed if he continues to struggle.
He is a good 3RW long term for us.

 

[Geardedandbearded]

There shouldn't be any concern. Oilers will breeze into playoffs with what they have. We don't need to add Rakell or Getzlaf.
Yama struggling this season is good for EDM long term. We might actually be able to get both him and Puljujarvi signed if he continues to struggle.
He is a good 3RW long term for us.

we talk about the long term so much we forget we live in the short term! Yamm will be a fine nhl player; idk if the oilers can wait around for him to solidify all his weaknesses.

 

[Zegs2sendhelp]

I do agree oilers focus should be less about long term and more about winning a cup…. But this is too much

maybe you move a 1st, 2nd, prospect not named Bouchard for help up front or on blue line…. Really only way you should be moving farm is if a goalie like gibson is available.

Rakell at 50% would be a nice for oilers….
Manson at 50% bucks would prob be a solid
Obviously lindholm and Gibson would be ideal pick ups but lindholm price for half year prob isn’t worth it cause oilers can’t sign him

 

[DrDangles]

I'd certainly hope the Pens would be in on Manson. RD is a bit of a question mark after Letang and Marino, and adding another defensive oriented D would be ideal IMO.

What are the Ducks' needs prospect wise?