Oh boy... apparently the Subban - Weber trade has derailed general hockey judgement on HFBoards.
In what world is Malkin not a superstar ? It's been pretty simple, he's been the 2nd best center in the league behind his own teammate. And how is 31 years old now the indicator that an elite player becomes useless / too old ? Boy wouldn't we be talking about Chelios if things happened like that... 20 to 30 = elite, best player in the world, huge potential. Hit 31 = crappiest player ever, should be bought out, best years obviously behind. Didn't Alex Kovalev hit his 2nd best ever year with the Canadiens while being 35 years old ?
Great for the Flames they have a huge young stud and they should surely hang on to him. The reason they say no is because they are clearly out of competition for the next few years so acquiring a high prime asset simply doesn't put them into contention whatsoever... Other than that, I can't see in any way that Calgary would say no to Malkin if they were into contention mode. If I compare to Galchenyuk, with all the potential he's got and all we project into him, I don't look back at all at trading him for Malkin.
Subban for Weber made much more sense since their value is much closer than that. They are both elite right now, established and greatly producing, so they could be considered just about equal. You could concede a slight advantage to Subban for the age factor, but clearly not more than that.