BigGreenAlum
Registered User
- May 4, 2007
- 163
- 5
Well to me discussing the finer points of the strength of prospects coming from the CHL vs NCAA and their historical impact on the NHL is a whole thread in and of itself. But that discussion will be very one sided because its painstakingly obvious the CHL has produced more elite scoring talent, which I think you've already mentioned in this thread.
The deal is this: this a new era in NCAA Men's Div. I Hockey. The league has become much more defensive-minded and lower scoring than in the days of Kariya. The landscape of the league as a whole has drastically changed with the realignment which you have touched on. We're seeing the percentage of NHL players coming from NCAA development backgrounds rising to an all time high. Albeit mainly players serving in bottom-6F/bottom-4 D capacities. But it is still very hard to say, at this point, what Connor's season means in terms of his potential NHL ceiling and how to put it all into perspective going forward. I think he'll write his own story better than any we can predict with our amateur analysis with player comparables and NHLe, ect.
Im much more interested in what Connor needs to do to take the next step in his development and what is best for him next season, NCAA vs turing pro. I think he's ready for the AHL (best route for his development IMHO) but I do think he should maybe go back for another season in NCAA to really bare down and focus more of the defensive side of the puck.
+1 for this thoughtful post. The new era of the NCAA makes discussing whether Connor would put up 2 ppg in the OHL (like Marner, Strome, etc.) or how his NCAA output compares to others (Eichel/Larkin/Gaurdreau/Kariya etc.) is rather pointless. The real issue of projecting him as an NHLer and he will chart his own course better than any "amateur analysis".
As far as next year, I believe he should stay in the NCAA and use the extra time to continue to get bigger/faster/stronger. Michigan has a long history of Berenson saying essentially "if a player is ready for the NHL, I'll gladly support that decision, but to leave and play in the AHL is something I am not on board with." I do not think Michigan views him as NHL ready in terms of strength and I presume that will be a selling point by the Michigan staff to come back for one more season.
To illustrate, North Dakota defense first mentality manhandled Michigan on the weekend and Connor's line struggled a bit against that defensive pressure. Connor needs to gain man strength to be effective as an NHLer and he can gradually bulk up at Michigan in season and turn pro after next season versus playing for the Moose. If he was fully physically developed my opinion might differ.