so I am replying specifically to your comment. But this is in no way meant to speak directly to you or look like I’m trying to argue or contradict you specifically. I have seen several comments in the same kind of vein as you are making above not just here but in my feeds and on other internet places as I scroll around looking for any news give the dog days of summer….. so my comment is speaking to things generally but using your note to frame the reference and save some typing, given my rep of not shutting up and writing toooooo long posts on here
Canes management did not view TDA as top d pairing player even after he played here for the season and played well for us. While he did well for us on Slavin pairing, the brutally honest evaluators and stats guys along with the rest of the team leadership collective viewed TDA in an ideal roster scenario as being a lower pair guy and thus offered him a contract at that value. TDA parlayed Slavin making all his partners look amazing into a nice contract for himself with Philly when we couldn’t agree on his role and value and we went out and got Burns.
we still have Burns and now we got TDA back on a similar value contract that is more of a 3rd pair cap hit. It took Philly paying a chunk of the bill, but to the Cames org, they held fast and are paying what they want and see as his value.
Even if TDA gets good ice time and has success for us again, I just don’t see us paying him middle d pair money next season after we are basically on record twice now as valuing him as a bottom pairing cap hit player… and technically three times if you count the 1m flyer we took trying to get a steal of a deal… we didn’t sign him to a 4m 1 year deal, we paid him 1m for a year expecting him to be the third pair guy and maybe get good production from the third pair. Nor do I see us giving him 3 or more years of term. That’s just not how we roll…
I Wish TDA all the success in the world this season because if he is successful this year that bodes well for the Canes team‘s success hopefully.. but the only way I see TDA playing higher than third pairing is if we have injuries to those players higher up the lineup. And TDA has his work cut out for him to unseat Chatfield at regular rotation of 3rd pairing right d…. Brindy stuck with Chat in that spot all year. Only time he got moved out of that spot was to play higher in the lineup, not to sit for another player….
I see Brindy introducing the 2f-3D formation before I see TDA playing consistently over Chatfield at 3rd pair right d and chatty sitting in the press box….**** Assuming we have all our higher pair players on the roster to start the season ******
If Skjei and Pesce are still here opening night into the season and we have Orlov playing LD on the third freaking pair to keep those two guys together as our shutdown pairing, it’s going to be 2F-3D rosters or we play a lot of nights with 7d and 11 forwards giving lots of double shift opportunities for our top 3 centers and being creative finding shifts for TDA…..Or Burns moves to the wing to make room for more d men to play