Well first off that’s not true. Crosby has done it 6 times actually. He was tied for 5th in ‘13 while missing 1/4 of the season. Meanwhile, Draisaitl has only done it three times, in ‘19, ‘20 and ‘21. And Crosby doesn’t have more because of injuries lol. How is that not obvious? He finished just outside multiple times while missing games and even this season is out scoring Draisaitl. He has 14 seasons where he’s played at least 75% of the games and his ES finishes in those are 7, 10, 4, 3, T-5, 1, 7, 2, 4, T-26, 9, T-13, 35, 7. He was top 10 every healthy year from age 18-29 and has 2 more years in the top 10 since turning 30. Draisaitl is currently tied for 12th, with a 35 year old Crosby ahead of him.
Meanwhile, Crosby’s per game ES numbers through his prime blow away the rest of the league. Here’s the ES point leaders for the period between 09-10 and 13-14:
1.H.Sedin 259
2.St.Louis 258
3.Crosby 249
4.Stamkos 245
5.Ovechkin 244
6.Kane 243
7.Perry 237
8.Kessel 229
9.D.Sedin 225
10.Getzlaf 224
And the ES PPG for those players looks like this:
1.Crosby 0.96
2.Stamkos 0.74
3.H.Sedin 0.71
4.St.Louis 0.70
5.Ovechkin 0.69
6.Kane 0.69
7.D.Sedin 0.67
8.Getzlaf 0.66
9.Perry 0.64
10.Kessel 0.63
Drai’s last 5 years he’s 2nd in the league in ES points behind McDavid, and the leaders look like this:
1.McDavid 352
2.Draisaitl 318
3.Panarin 294
4.Matthews 291
4.MacKinnon 291
6.Marner 287
7.Kane 280
8.Gaudreau 279
9.Tkachuk 265
10.Pastrnak 258
11.Crosby 255
But the per game numbers for those players look like this:
1.McDavid 0.99
2.MacKinnon 0.89
3.Matthews 0.88
4.Draisaitl 0.87
5.Panarin 0.86
6.Marner 0.84
7.Crosby 0.80
8.Kane 0.79
9.Pastrnak 0.78
10.Gaudreau 0.77
11.Tkachuk 0.73
So Crosby’s per game numbers were way above the pack whereas Draisaitl has been within the pack of players under McDavid, and despite ES scoring being lower at the time, Crosby’s per game numbers were also better than Draisaitl’s. in fact, a 31-35 year old Crosby has been as close to prime Draisaitl the past 5 years than Draisaitl has been compared to prime Crosby.
Crosby was easily the better ES scorer than Draisaitl through his prime, and when combined with the fact that he was a better possession player and had a greater impact on GF%, was a decent amount better at ES. Draisaitl has been a better PP player, but there’s zero argument for him being better at ES.