Yeah we are the opposite on this topic.
For example I thought Ty Smith's mechanics looked good, but was just slow. Holtz I think is kind of in this boat as well. Boucher another. It's super rare for guys to go from slow to not slow, let alone to fast, which I'll say never happens.
I do agree on the distinction between acceleration(I often refer to as quickness) vs top end speed. Guys can be one but not the other. Wood, especially this past year was def more fast then quick.
I also agree on a high IQ/good work ethic guy is more likely to improve, then guy lower in those categories.
I didn’t have a huge problem with Smith’s skating, his problem was more that he got pushed around like a large child in tighter areas and it led to his confidence imploding.
I thought Smith was going to get stronger/sturdier than he did at that point. He had just turned 22 in his last games with us, he still can get stronger.
I veer into what feels like (badly) ladysplaining male physiology on this board and it feels weird at best.
Male muscle strength peaks later in the 20s, around ~25-30. (I read that on the internet, not a lot of personal experience with that sort of thing.) So Smith, like other smaller players, could peak later.
Larger players can gain more speed easier, though people sometimes assume that’s a given. Skating expectations for smaller players are basically sky high because they have to make up for their size disadvantage.
I edited my original post down though, I swear we aren’t completely at odds. I had “unless the player is very slow” as a problem somewhere, it’s not like I don’t believe in speed as concept or something. I’m not a weirdo contrarian. (I swear.)
I just think strength can help in some ways and some mechanics are more fixable than others. (And only some players put in the work and/or get the guidance needed to correctly fix them.)
Boucher’s skating was so bad there was a question if he would even get drafted. And his skating did improve, starting in his D+1 season, and he did almost make it. His skating went from awful to not that good though.
A lack of size, not great speed or agility, and poor puck skills was too tough to overcome with just scoring ability (and he turned out to be a shitty person too, so there’s that).
Holtz is really more of pace thing to me, he just plays the game slower. If he tried to skate around like a maniac he wouldn’t be playing his game. He tries to slow the game down that’s very difficult to do unless you’re an elite player.
When a team drafts a player they have to figure out if his skills and play style will work in the NHL. If our team have buyer’s remorse with Holtz then they didn’t think through what kind of player he would be when he got here. (Seriously, you didn’t have to be hockey Nostradamus to see this coming.)
But obviously more speed and better skating from him would help him too.