This is one of those nights where Babcock frustrates me so incredibly much. So he's sending Matthews and Marner out there again. They haven't worked at all, and especially not tonight. They have no chemistry at all. But he keeps them together because he wants to match them against Bergeron, which is fine if they could get some results there. But they don't. They get completely OWNED. But he doesn't adapt. He just keeps walking into the same trap. All to keep Nylander away from Bergeron so we wouldn't get these breakdowns... that we saw pretty much every shift. And Willy had one of those games where he did his job defensively. In the process, our two best players were neutralized, some of the best chemistry on the team was not utilized, and we give Boston a huge advantage.
Good
Kerfoot - Outside the penalty drawn and one so-so giveaway, Kerfoot was amazing. He was flying with the puck, making smart plays, and creating offense.
Nylander - Pretty good game. Nothing bad, but a list of good topped by that great cross-ice pass. Halfway back to the way he played the first five-six games.
Kapanen - People lost it earlier this season. Kap struggled as a LW, but he wasn't the sole problem on that line. Back in a more ideal position, he looks like an impact player.
Muzzin - Muzzin is one of those players that if you just watch the game, you might not come away impressed. If you focus on him though... he's just so damn good. He gives no space, he contests every puck, and he's got the patience and smarts to make very good transition plays. He plays with considerable risk, which results in some bad plays, but the overall is so positive.
Holl - If this was what Holl could have brought last year, we made a big mistake not giving him ice time. He looks great. If it wasn't for difference in usage, I'd say he's been our best RD.
Fine
Johnsson - Johnsson had some great moments, but I have no idea how you enter a game with a heavy focus on discipline and take two dumb penalties in a row.
Mikheyev - Considered putting him in bad. I didn't like his decision-making tonight, and I didn't feel like he had a lot of impact. I don't think he was that bad though.
Gauthier - Not a hallmark performance for Goat, but he still looks like an effective NHLer out there. That's so much more than I expected.
Moore - Another player I considered putting as bad. He really struggled handling the puck tonight, but I think his tenacity and the space it opens up warranted a better grade.
Shore - Could have just put the entire fourth line under the same. Didn't do much, but they did their job. Decent results in defensive minutes.
Petan - See Shore.
Timashov - See Petan.
Barrie - See Nytro. Just kidding. Barrie was fine. But we traded for a difference maker, a dynamic offensive player. He's not shown any of that.
Bad
Matthews - Complete no show, and bad defensively. I know it's the Bergeron line, but I caught him several times far away from where he should be.
Marner - Similar to Matthews. Did nothing. And somehow he's gone from taking bad shots way too often to ignoring good opportunities. Happy medium is hard to find.
Rielly - I have no idea how anyone can watch Rielly and come away thinking he's good defensively.
Ceci - I have no idea how anyone can watch Ceci and come away thinking he's a hockey player.
Gravel - It's been a rocky road... No, I'm not going there. Gravel had the absolutely right idea of what he should be doing. He just couldn't do it. At all.
Hutchinson - I know he had a bunch of great saves, but that's four goals against in a game where I lost count of how many times a transition opportunity turned into offense for them thanks to his puckhandling. I can't recall seeing a goaltender screw up handling the puck this much before.