I was disappointed that he wasn't resigned last season, not for lack of effort by Dubas if reports are true.
Listen, I've stated I'm not into the fighting brand of hockey, but there are times when it serves a purpose, often to protect your players when the refs won't. Recall Simmonds taking exception last year to players hitting his goalie and he struck back. God Bless him for that. Most teams who lose their starting goalie are in deep trouble. Look at how a freak accident to Tavares probably cost the Leafs a series. I don't like how soft the Leafs look in after-the-whistle scrum in general.
More importantly, he's a big, willing, bruising body who can be a wingman for Simmonds if need be, something I believe could have made a crash line had he resigned last season. Yes, he will be buried in the minors, but Kyle knows the player, he likes him (so do I after seeing him play a smart, solid game in his role, i.e no stupid penalties or unnecessary roughness) so he would have no hesitation in calling him up and every player would welcome it.
You need balance in your lineup. Different looks and attitude/presence (I love that word since Dubas used it). When a guy has won multiple Cups and has kept himself in the league by being an effective physical presence, all players regardless of their salary or talent will listen when he speaks.