Small Things Like These (2024) Directed by Tim Mielants
7A
In 1985 in a small village in Ireland, Bill Furlong (Cillian Murphy), who delivers heavy bags of coal to different residences, makes a stop at the local nunnery and sees something he shouldn't, a young woman being forced through the door of the convent. Still struggling with his own past demons, he is deeply troubled by this. He believes he has witnessed one of the Catholic Church darkest transgressions, the Magdalene Laundries, abusive places where unwed pregnant girls (around 57,000 in total) were forced to go and where their infants were almost invariably taken from them at birth. The rest of the movie is basically a quiet
tour de force for Murphy as Bill struggles with his conscience about what to do. His wife, indeed, even the local bar keep, wants him to forget what he has seen because he might do something that could harm the Church whose power in small-town Ireland even at this late date is still all encompassing. His will is pitted against the Mother Superior of the convent played chillingly by Emily Watson who has no qualms whatsoever about wielding her power.
This is a small thing itself of a movie, but its impact is formidable. Most of Bill's plight is communicated visually as we watch Murphy painfully contend with his own misgivings. He is part of a culture that ignores the abuses of the Church, and it is obviously no small feat to contemplate doing something which could affect at great personal cost his wife and five daughters, whose schooling the nuns have control over. What a follow-up this is to Murphy's Oscar winning performance in
Oppenheimer. I'm not sure that Murphy's performance here isn't superior. He manages to communicate a whole lifetime of reticence and emotional restraint, a man not used to making waves of any kind. Like the novel that it was taken from,
Small Things Like These bears eloquent witness to the importance of a good man not allowing himself to look the other way.
Sidenote: I was surprised that the movie was set as late as 1985. I then remembered that the last infamous Residential School in Canada wasn't closed until 1997.
For those who do not know, Residential Schools refer to Canada's state sponsored schools, affecting around 150,000 indigenous children, run primarily by the Catholic Church but including significant involvement from other Christian denominations where abuse was rampant and not infrequently fatal (at least 6509 deaths for sure, but it is impossible to know the complete number as the children were usually buried in unmarked graves). Canada's House of Commons in 2022 unanimously concluded that what occurred in these schools was genocide.
Best of 2024 so far
- Anora, Baker, US
- Flow, Zilbalodis, Latvia
- Caught by the Tides, Jia, China
- All We Imagine As Light, Kapadia, India
- Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World, Jude, Romania
- Green Border, Holland, Poland
- Heretic, Beck and Woods, US
- The Seed of the Sacred Fig, Rasoulof, Germany
- Small Things Like These, Mielants, Ireland
- Here, Devos, Belgium