Caught by the Tides (2024) Directed by Jia Zhang-ke
9B
Caught by the Tides is a hybrid, one-of-a-kind film that contains some gorgeous, almost miscellaneous documentary footage as well as a narrative that takes place roughly over a twenty-year period. The story entails a quest by one partner to find the other in the soon-to-be-transformed Three Gorges area on Northern China. We have met the protagonists before in Jia's masterpiece
Still Life, one of my two favourite films of the 21st century. In that film, Qiao travels to Fengzie, a city that will soon be under water thanks to a huge damn project on the Yangtze River. Though he doesn't seem much of a catch, she has fallen in love with Bin despite his sometimes poor treatment of her, and she goes to great lengths to find him.
Caught by the Tides could be thought of as a sequel to the earlier film though it is unlike any sequel ever made.
For starters, most of the "story" footage is taken from
Still Life and other Jia films over the past twenty years. The naturalistic "documentary" shots are more recent, and it all fits together in a way that is somehow both pleasing and startling. The first 45 minutes of this roughly two hour movie is made up mainly of what I would call "establishing shots." And they are wondrous. I am at a loss to explain why, but no director I know of can shoot faces and small groups of people better than Jia does. The faces linger with you--each stray person seems to reveal great depths of hope, lassitude, loss, decrepitude, whatever. By the time the story finally got under way, I sort of wished it hadn't. I was just content to follow Jia's restless camera, virtually a character in the film, as it moved around peeking over people's shoulders or strolling through a crowd. It made me realize how unreliant Jia's works are on dialogue.
So we do have a culmination of this strange romance, but really the movie has so many different facets beside that, things that in a way the unhappy romance symbolizes: social change that is too rapid for its people; hopeful youth; disenfranchised old people; business hustlers; robots and modern technology; Covid; music, which is everywhere; recovery and loss (not the other way around); the growing pains of a nation that finds some of its poorest people expendable; and finally, a big one, images that tell a story better than words ever can. While I don't underrate the significant benefit of being already familiar with Jia's work and thematic preoccupations, I think the sheer brilliance of the film making and the beauty of the images justify an enthusiastic recommendation. Like many great works of art, ultimately
Caught by the Tides plays by its own rules and thrives doing so. And it teaches us a lot that we could never learn in any other way about its real subject: China.
Sidenote: Though I know no one asked, I keep wanting to complete Jia's title for him. My version:
Caught by the Tides in the Stream of History. That seems to sum up contemporary China pretty well.
subtitles
Best of '24 so far
1) Flow, Zilbalodis, Latvia
2) Caught by the Tides, Jia, China
3) All We Imagine As Light, Kapadia, India
4) Do Not Expect Too Much from the End of the World, Jude, Romania
5) Green Border, Holland, Poland
6) The Seed of the Sacred Fig, Rasoulof, Germany
7) Here, Devos, Belgium
8) Pictures of Ghosts, Filho, Brazil
9) Hit Man, Linklater, US
10)The Substance, Fargeat, US