Osprey
Registered User
- Feb 18, 2005
- 27,922
- 10,805
Can anyone tell me if War and Peace is worth a watch? Not normally a question I would ask, but we are talking about an 8+ hr movie here.
You're in luck. We happen to have someone here crazy enough to watch an 8-hour Russian movie in one sitting and with no bathroom breaks.
kihei said:
War and Peace (1968) Directed by Sergey Bondarchuk 9A
Having just sat through this 7+ hour adaptation of War and Peace in one sitting, I came away very impressed. Originally the movie was intended to show that in terms of epics Russia could compete with Hollywood and anyone else in the world. Further it was a form of revenge to be taken on the disastrously bad Hollywood version of War and Peace that starred Henry Fonda and Audrey Hepburn. That massively edited Hollywood abomination was largely seen as a desecration of a national treasure in the Soviet Union. So Sergey Bondarchuk, not exactly a young lion but not a member of the old guard either, was provided with virtually an unlimited budget and as many extras as he needed, courtesy of the Red Army, and instructed to make the definitive film version of Leo Tolstpy's great novel. The end result is an epic film that is remarkably faithful to the sprawling novel while setting new standards for battle sequences that have yet to be matched to this day without the help of CGI. War and Peace is a historical romance that deals with both Napoleon's attempts to reach Moscow and thus control Russia and with the fates of three people whose lives are caught up in these turbulent times: Natasha, the youthful, graceful princess who wears her heart on her sleeve; Prince Andrey, aloof and aristocratic who falls in love with her despite his better judgement; and Pierre, kind-hearted but of low birth, who always somehow finds himself at the centre of great events. How their personal fortunes play out amidst the backdrop of the cataclysmic seismic shifts of history is at the heart of both the novel and the movie. The first four hours of the movie focus on the romantic intrigue but does include the battle of Austerlitz which the French won; during the final three hours, romance takes a back seat as war dominates everything. The battle at Borodino and the failure of the French to hold Moscow, both beautifully photographed and edited, dominate this part of the movie, which includes battle sequences of a prolonged duration, like 45 minutes, that are as breathtaking to behold today as they were half a century ago. Not just film buffs, but European literature aficionados and military historians should find War and Peace well worth its imposing running time.
subtitles
available on the Criterion Channel