Don't need to use +/- you could use analytics.
Out of defenseman that have played 50 or more 5on5 time he ranks out of 192nd:
180th in xGF%, 184th in shot attempts for %, 181st in shots for %
Hutson has given up the 6th most scoring chances against, 11th most high danger shot attempts against, 4th most xGA, 3rd most shot attempts against.
He's getting killed out there defensively. Things don't look much better if you do the per 60 stats. He preforms slightly better in the raw numbers but he's still one of the worst preforming defenseman in the the league defensively.