I keep Kempe over Moore every day of the week.
Not for me. Moore has only 11 fewer points the previous three seasons, while playing considerably fewer "favorable" minutes (less powerplay time, helped Danault prop up Athanasiou last season, etc).
Kempe has a better shot and better speed, but he's far less disciplined and more streaky.
Is Kaliyev really that defensively bad though? Wasn't that the entire point of last season? To keep him in a limited role on the 4th line so he can become a better all around player, his board play is pretty great, and I don't really ever notice him making consistent D blunders. Although I do agree he should be playing with Danault and Moore.
I don't even think Kaliyev is "that bad" defensively. I just don't think he's been in situations where he's been challenged defensively,
I'd be fine with trying Kaliyev with Danault. Good probability Kaliyev isn't ready for the extra work that line gets. He is improving quickly. When will he be ready for the extra responsibility? Weeks, Months? End of year? Next Season? Don't know. The cap is going to force a turnover with the roster in the near future & he was on Kopi's line last night after the line blender. Got edged out by Vilardi's crazy start. He'll get a chance.
Just out of curiosity, why isn't Kaliyev ready for the extra work?
Kaliyev did not look good when they moved him up this year, same with last year. It's why it's short lived. That was the 3rd line however.
I would like to see him tried with Kopitar in any case. I don't think Vilardi is the best fit on that line as he and Kopi often tend to occupy the same space. Kempe stays wider, and Kaliyev tends to like the high slot. I think they would complement each other. Arty is doing great where he's at so no rush, but while I see him as Moore's replacement, I think he would slot in better next to Anze.
These are the top 30 line combinations involving Kaliyev (by ice time) at even strength last season:
36% of the time he was with Lizotte and Lemieux. The second highest was with Danault and Moore, which was a grand total of 80 minutes all season (which, with his ice time, is about 9 games if we're assuming 9 minutes TOI at even strength). Net positive of goals and shots for (2 GF, 1 GA; 54 SF, 32 SA). In fact, his worst was a whole 16 minutes with Vilardi and Tkachev, where there were 2 goals against and the line was outshot 7-3.
These stats aren't be-all, end-all, but it helps paint a picture that he can hold his own with more responsibility when he gets it.
42 minutes with Kopitar and Kempe wasn't good either, though, as that was a net negative of 2 goals against, but it's not like Kaliyev was the only one to suffer from that. The line of Kempe - Kopitar - Arvidsson was a net -4 (1 GF, 5 GA) in only 36 minutes together. That's less time than Kaliyev with Kopitar and Kempe. Perhaps we should send Arvidsson down to the 4th line to work on his game instead?