Neighbours really wasn't that hyped, we always viewed him as a middle 6 guy.
I've seen him hyped as a 2nd line guy. He's not, nor should he ever be - at least in the NHL. But by definition a "middle 6" guy would imply either a 2nd line or 3rd line player.
For the beginning part of the season, this board spoke about how he wasn't ready and should be in the minors. After his call up, his play definitely improved for stretches, but what did you genuinely expect out of his this year?
He should have been in the minors all season long, learning how to play defense. Given that the organization wasn't going to do that absent him playing shitty - like he did earlier this season - I would have expected him to play harder on offense to somewhat offset his defense. He didn't do that, either. [Nor do I expect him to do that going forward.]
Of course he didn't get as much criticism, the expectations for him and the standard for him was always a hell of a lot lower than any of our top 6 forwards or top 4 defensemen.
I'm pretty sure I was around when we took him. I know I
hated that pick from the moment it was announced. As in, I haven't hated a 1st-round pick of ours like that since we took Jordan Schmaltz (who I wanted us to trade ASAP before the rest of the league caught on to how bad he was). But I seem to recall people being thrilled about it and hyping him as a 2nd-line guy, and as he was doing his thing in the WHL it gave off all the vibes I recall when people got excited about Brett Sonne when he won WHL Player of the Year honors. [And if the archives were still around, you'd find my criticism of him and my criticism of everyone's excitement about him.]
If there's one player that probably gets an undeserved pass at time, it's Schenn. I'm a big fan of his, but he's inconsistent, part of that might be because he plays through so many injuries due to his style, but it's still inconsistencies.
I agree with this, but Schenn gets the pass because as you note, when he plays hard he's going to leave it all on the ice. I'd rather him dial that back a bit and spread that effort across the season.