It certainly was talked about leading into the '14 draft.
1OA for 8OA + 25y/o, 30g JvR
OP wasn't claiming it should be done today. Just merely trying to have some conversation on how the proposal stands up and what needs to change.
I believe that was the leafs offer.. Not the asking price from Florida
clearly a leafs fan.
If u wanna talk Ekblad, u gotta offer Matthews + Top 4 D like Rielly/Gardiner.
EKblad> Rielly at this point.
you dont give up Marner, Nylander and a shot at patrick/liljegren to make up that difference. this isnt Doughty we are talking about.
Mclellan has already said Rielly has been their best player so far.
50 pts with 1st unit PP time this season
If Ekblad asked to be traded (the only reason the Panther would trade him) the cost would be something like Reilly+Marner+2nd or Reilly+Nylander+2nd. The difference between Ekblad and Reilly is not Matthews.
Personally I think Matthews looks better than Eichel... so not sure I would even trade Matthews straight across for Ekblad, unless my team was in desperate need for D and I had a fair amount of forward depth.
You think he can hit 50 this year? I got him at 40-45 myself
I like you. Arguing with everyone in the discussion. EkblaD is already one best dmen in the league.
If the leafs want Ekblad the discussion starts with Matthews. Remember I am not a panther fan.
and the leafs would politely decline and that would be that. Matthews is giving Mcdavid a run for his money as best forward on NA. I think they are more than happy with what Rielly has done (the last min of the guy was all Morgan) and expect him to grow into a #1Dman.
The difference between Rielly and Ekblad isnt Matthews. thats beyond silly. Thats like the leafs asking for Trouba + Laine for Rielly
Thats like the leafs asking for Trouba + Laine for Matthews
nah, pretty sure that was the panthers ask and the leafs balked
JVR was coming off a 30/30 year and the top of the draft was considered to be weaker than normal.
the leafs may have taken reinhart/bennett in that spot.
would they move JVR + Nylander for either of those guys? not a chance.
EKblad is the only guy at the top of that draft that has that kinda value
sorry
I believe that is the leaf spin doctors and rewriting of history that offer
It would take Mathews to get the conversation started and then TO would have to add enough to make them believe that they are becoming a better team. Trading your #1D for a great prospect doesn't make any team better, it leaves a team with a huge hole in their lineup and that is why it would take much more to get Eckblad.
The Leafs would not propose this deal either, they look like they have a plan and they are going to stick to it.
players the leafs would move Matthews for: Mcdavid...that is all
but arent both Trouba and Laine > Rielly?
It should read:
and the leafs would politely decline and that would be that. Matthews is giving Mcdavid a run for his money as best forward on NA. I think they are more than happy with what Rielly has done (the last min of the guy was all Morgan) and expect him to grow into a #1Dman.
The difference between Rielly and Ekblad isnt Matthews. thats beyond silly. Thats like the leafs asking for Trouba + Laine for Rielly
Lmao. Oh my God.
Lmao. Oh my God.
nope, pretty sure it was Bobby Mac on tsn.
leafs wanted to move up to grab Reinhart/Bennett (finally getting a #1C prospect). The ask was JVR + 8OA. thank god they didnt do it