Both of those kids have more upside yes absolutely but neither are where Barron already is
Agree to disagree
Based on the very limited sample size, I believe Reinbacher was more solid than Barron, and Barron better than Mailloux, who was even with Engstrom. Oeville has been the best at breaking up plays and sending the team back up ice with possession.
Hutson has more peaks and more valleys than the other four.
Struble is ahead of all the rookies and ahead of Barron too, but behind Xhekaj.
I don't think a rookie should be the consistent 7th D. Personally, I would have Reinbacher in the top 6 and Barron 7th, with Hutson going to Laval to improve his defence, along with Mailloux and Engstrom.
Most fans might flip Reinbacher and Hutson, and I would keep my mind open for that over the next four games and balance of training camp.