This thread is starting to remind me of Grumpy Old Men.
At the very least it has to be an option. There has to be fluidity there. How long should he be on the 4th line? How much progress would he have to show? If he's good enough to stay on the 4th line but doesn't show any growth there, how long would you allow that to go on for?
My point is that I think the AHL/NHL argument isn't the right argument to have necessarily. Management or even fans shouldn't be locked into one way or another. What you want to see is them accepting the dynamism of the situation as it continues. It shouldn't just be one league or another and that's that.
Management and again the fans should keep both options open as the season progresses. If management doesn't even see the AHL as a potential option at ANY point, that could be a problem.
He's a really tough one to gage and that's why the debate is as heated as it is. When arguments are that heated it invariably means that both sides have relevant points.Well, tough to disagree with anything here.
Still, unless Slaf play start trending in the wrong direction, its tough to envision him being sent down right now. But like you said, its an evolutive situation but if his plays is trending down then not only should we consider send him down but that would as red as a flag it could be possibly be.
Newhook or Monahan should be the third winger.Given that Slaf is starting in the NHL, I hope he plays on a line with Dach and gets a lot of minutes.
I'm not sure who should be winger #3.
Given that Slaf is starting in the NHL, I hope he plays on a line with Dach and gets a lot of minutes.
I'm not sure who should be winger #3.
I hope not, RHP and Slafkovsky end up playing the same type of roll of puck cycler and screening the goalie.It looks like the plan is Slaf-Dach-RHP.
This is not a real argument and isn’t a valid statement. It’s pushed by bad faith commentators who use it to rationalize HuGo’s decision to keep Slafkovsky in the NHL.Now the argument is that the AHL has far more head hunters there and could be in more danger down there.
Great post. Perfect example of little plays that aren't fancy but create great scoring chances because Slafkovsky is using his reach to his advantage. He also that hook pass that is underrated. Not fancy looking, but super effective.
Some nice little Slaf highlights.
I love the third video I think the most. The single highlight against Jersey. It is a dump and chase. The puck is dumped into the corner. Slaf goes in....takes a bump from the Jersey player who tries to tie him up. A second Jersey player goes for the puck. Slaf shrugs it off and emerges from the boards with the puck.Great post. Perfect example of little plays that aren't fancy that create great scoring chances because Slafkovsky is using his reach to his advantage. He also that hook pass that is underrated. Not fancy looking, but super effective.
This is the highlight package for a guy who just went first overall? Just about anyone in the NHL can make plays like that. And Grant McGagg is reaching because he went all in on Slafkovsky before the draft and started spitting in everyone’s face because he made the prediction that Montreal would take him.
Some nice little Slaf highlights.
I hope not, RHP and Slafkovsky end up playing the same type of roll of puck cycler and screening the goalie.
There was a couple of points yesterday where Slaf was in the high slot ready to tip, and then RHP skates in like 3 feet behind him for the same spot. The puck gets the deflected to the corner and no one is any position to challenge defenders for the loose puck.
That was just one example. I find they just end up trying to do the same thing and they are not in sync. It's just not a good fit at all.
Also, RHP has not had a good camp at all. He's been completely invisible, I'm not sure he really deserves that chair at the moment. This coming from a huge fan of his play last year. He's there to help create room with his intensity and board play and he's done exactly 0 of that in camp.
Caufield Suzuki Anderson
Newhook Dach Slafkovsky
Pearson Monahan Heineman
Ylonen/RHP Evans Gallagher
This is how I'd match it up based on performances in camp.
If you are expecting Bedard level highlights, that simply is not going to happen. He is a different player with a different skillset. Sometimes the highlights don't just smack you right in the face.This is the highlight package for a guy who just went first overall? Just about anyone in the NHL can make plays like that. And Grant McGagg is reaching because he went all in on Slafkovsky before the draft and started spitting in everyone’s face because he made the prediction that Montreal would take him.
It's really shocking how low expectations have gotten with this guy.This is the highlight package for a guy who just went first overall? Just about anyone in the NHL can make plays like that. And Grant McGagg is reaching because he went all in on Slafkovsky before the draft and started spitting in everyone’s face because he made the prediction that Montreal would take him.
I've been trying to find some Nemec, Wright, Jiricek and Cooley highlight packages from the pre-season. I've seen Cooley's dangle. That was sweet. Hoping to see more of what they have been able to do this pre-season. Please share if you have access!!It's really shocking how low expectations have gotten with this guy.
It's going to get really fiesty when Nemec and Wright and Jiricek and Cooley start to show what they have in the NHL. (mod)
Most of that package isn’t highlights, it’s just cherrypicking nice puck touches or pinches which even the lowest level players are expected to make when they make the NHL.If you are expecting Bedard level highlights, that simply is not going to happen. He is a different player with a different skillset. Sometimes the highlights don't just smack you right in the face.
Disagree.Slaf chases Marner from the Leafs zone and keeps pace with him. Mailloux standing there and Slaf stuck to Marner, causes Marner to go wide across the ice. Mathews steps up to the gap. Slaf's attention was focused on Marner all the way down the ice. Matthews was in his six the entire time. Mailloux should have seen Matthews coming, and once Marner showed he was letting up, Mailloux's attention should have shifted to Matthews. Or......another Hab could have actually back checked. This wasn't on Slaf, and shouldn't really be on Mailloux either.
Look at these two screen grabs.....the first one shows the start of the play. We see Mailloux pivoting at the blue line and Slaf parallel with Marner. Then we see two habs behind Marner and I think one of the two Leafs is Matthews.
View attachment 748523
5 seconds later.....Matthews is streaking in on his own....while one of those Habs players is on OV controller mode in the neutral zone. Looked bad at first on Slaf or Mailloux, but honestly it wasn't them who f***ed this up.
View attachment 748524
I appreciate what McCagg is doing, but this is as pointless as people nitpicking his every shift.
Some nice little Slaf highlights.
Very good point.I appreciate what McCagg is doing, but this is as pointless as people nitpicking his every shift.
Pointing out his every mistake on the ice or pointing out every time he makes a good pass...
It's all the same.
Low expectations with Slafkovsky, in this fanbase especially?It's really shocking how low expectations have gotten with this guy.
It's going to get really fiesty when Nemec and Wright and Jiricek and Cooley start to show what they have in the NHL. (mod)
Slafkovsky never "had" Matthews...Slafkovsky was on Marner as soon as Marner picked up the puck high in the Leafs zone.Disagree.
When Slaf lost Matthews, he should have seen Mailloux now had the job and should have then paid attention to the open ice he had created in his back and where Marner slipped in.
I'd tell you to go look at the Devils, Blue Jackets and Coyotes board for the latest take on each respective prospect.I've been trying to find some Nemec, Wright, Jiricek and Cooley highlight packages from the pre-season. I've seen Cooley's dangle. That was sweet. Hoping to see more of what they have been able to do this pre-season. Please share if you have access!!