Carter has the edge in numbers. Voracek just completed his 5th year in the NHL. Through 5 years for both players.
GP G A Pts +/-
Voracek 367 79 150 229 +5
Carter 381 145 132 277 +24
Live in Philly, Flyers fan for over 40 years and have been a Kings fan since the mistake of trading Richards, and having seen all of Carter’s games and all of Voraceks as a Flyer, Carter is the better defender in all 3 zones by a margin. Voracek is an outstanding and explosive offense talent who is a lot of fun to watch. A great offensive player. But Carter is just as talented offensively, has a much deadlier wrist shot is a very very strong 2 way player, very solid on both sides of the puck. Jake, not so much , average to adequate.
The Flyers were in very capable hands with Carter and Richards, who as young players helped drive the team to 2 Conference finals (2008, 2010) and a SCF in 2010. The Flyers haven’t won a cup because of GOALTENDING, not Carter and Richards
.
And great at Clarke was, without Bernie Parent, no Cup then either. The Flyers Achilles heel for almost 30 years now has been goaltending. Homer’s poor management of the team, drafts and trades has put them in a bad position, esp CAP wise. They had a very good team in 2010, all they needed was to trade Leino (asking for $$$$) and get a top notch goalie. They chose not to , gutted the team instead and set themselves back years.
The Kings win the trade short term and long term. Without Richards, no Cup last year and an early exit this year. Dean has crafted a very good team, one of the youngest in the league and identified on the day of the Richards trade that he now had what he called the ‘four foundations’ of what a team needs to win and be a contender (positionally). A stud goalie, an elite defensemen and 2 stud centers. Because of that trade and the Carter trade, they’ll be contending for the Cup for years.
The Flyers are an incomplete team, no map, no outline or path, always a crap shoot, a ‘quick fix’ to ‘win now’ and swinging for the fences gets you more strikeouts then homeruns.