Wings fan here. Is there anything other than Larkin that Winnipeg fans would want? Could Tatar be the starter for a deal? What's his value? Would love to have him in DET.
As the Hall Larson deal shows defensemen are so hard to find that it took a proven top 5 wingers to get a a defensemen with potential of being a top 4 d-man
I am a Jets fan and I would say Larkin is not even a starting point. Larson and Trouba are not that far a part in value and Larkin is not at Hall's value.
This Larsson Trouba thing is getting old. Larsson is better numbers wise and better in a eye test to any unbiased fan. Larsson is on a nice long term deal.
Trouba is not and is not close in value.
The overrating of him by Jets fans is out of control. Hopefully he holds out.
Lulz. I promise you Larsson wasn't Chiarelli's first choice. One of the reasons that he'll be wearing copper and blue this year is that Trouba among other players couldn't be had for a similar price.
A good number of your fellow wings fans believe your team doesn't have the assets to acquire Trouba at all. Either things are really ugly in Detroit, or he's a little better than you're giving him credit for.
Considering how many Superstar X for Trouba threads get started here by non-Jet fans, I think I know which it is.
This Larsson Trouba thing is getting old. Larsson is better numbers wise and better in a eye test to any unbiased fan. Larsson is on a nice long term deal.
I'm not a Wings fan or a Jets fan.
I'm sure Larsson wasn't his first choice but I'm also sure Trouba was lower down in his list, if he's on it at all.
If he traded Hall for Trouba Edmonton would rightly riot. He'd have to be a complete idiot.
Yet his name seems to pop up on a trade thread every second day...seems pretty contradictory to your bold statement don't you think? obviously the masses from other teams disagree with you. I can certainly say Jets fans are not the one's proposing these offers.
Alright. Trouba has been overrated for a long time now but to this degree that some people do in this thread? Astonishing!
Keep him
This Larsson Trouba thing is getting old. Larsson is better numbers wise and better in a eye test to any unbiased fan. Larsson is on a nice long term deal.
Trouba is not and is not close in value.
The overrating of him by Jets fans is out of control. Hopefully he holds out.[/QUOTE]
Now, now, that's not a "Family Matters" like attitude
What numbers are these? From what I can see their numbers are near identical but Trouba has a slight edge in both P/60 and zone start adjusted shot metrics.
Same for the eye test? I like Larsson and I think he's a low end #1 D, and only a few W will return more than that. To my eye test, however, he doesn't skate well enough to be more than a low end #1D. Trouba plays with more risk in his game but is much more dynamic
Larsson played against the other teams top line every night, first pair. Trouba did not. I question whether Trouba is even a #1 at all when it is said and done. That is far from a sure thing.
The thing is, we have nothing else that's even close. After Trouba, the level of our U23 defensemen drops hard. We need Trouba very badly, which many fans of other teams don't seem to understand. And Trouba has had to carry Stuart and be in a team with Buff, which obviously limits his ice time.
I don't think I've seen a Winnipeg fan who wants to trade Trouba. 99,5% of the Trouba proposals are made by other teams' fans - and pretty much every single one of them is a lowball/a bunch of needless stuff. So call him overrated if you want, but it seems like Trouba is very hot commodity here...
Morrissey??? The guy is good.
Larsson played against the other teams top line every night, first pair. Trouba did not. I question whether Trouba is even a #1 at all when it is said and done. That is far from a sure thing.
Larsson averaged 22:30 a night last season, Trouba averaged 22:03. Trouba put up more points and had much better shot metrics. Trouba played with a far worse partner (Mark Staurt vs Andy Greene)
Larsson started a higher percentage of his shifts in the defensive but played with much better teammates. Both faced similar quality competition.
Trouba is a year and a half younger and already better than Larsson. If anything Trouba is getting massively underrated on these boards.
With a grand total of what, two NHL games, I do not consider him to be anywhere near Trouba.
Well you were saying just that nobody is available but Morrissey can step up next season I'm expecting him to take a spot on the starting roster this year in fact
Larsson played against the other teams top line every night, first pair. Trouba did not. I question whether Trouba is even a #1 at all when it is said and done. That is far from a sure thing.
Larsson averaged 22:30 a night last season, Trouba averaged 22:03. Trouba put up more points and had much better shot metrics. Trouba played with a far worse partner (Mark Staurt vs Andy Greene)
Larsson started a higher percentage of his shifts in the defensive but played with much better teammates. Both faced similar quality competition.
Trouba is a year and a half younger and is already at worst equal to Larsson. If anything Trouba is getting massively underrated on these boards.
Well minutes aside, Larsson faced the toughest competition on his team, Trouba was 4th. Of guys who played significant time this year Larsson faced about the 15th hardest competition in the league, Trouba about 65th. Trouba got fairly balanced starts, slightly favoring offensive starts, Larsson got literally the worst starts in the league. I would certainly hope Trouba had better shot metrics. It's also not like we are talking Trouba's offensive upside is Burns level. He might be a consistent 30 point guy, but given the same easy starts I don't doubt Larsson could be equal.
Also Trouba statistically digressed in 15-16 while Larsson at worst maintained.
I think Larsson is getting seriously **** on because of the Hall trade. He's by far the better player and I doubt that extra year is going to make Trouba the better player.
This Larsson Trouba thing is getting old. Larsson is better numbers wise and better in a eye test to any unbiased fan. Larsson is on a nice long term deal.
Trouba is not and is not close in value.
The overrating of him by Jets fans is out of control. Hopefully he holds out.