I will admit, I haven't read this whole thread, so if this information has been presented yet, forgive me. I see several of you comparing J.T. Miller to Brandon Dubinsky based on production and age. I found a few closer comparables:
(Based on 3 years-post draft AHL season [20-21 years old] and first full NHL season immediately following, who were drafted no earlier than 2006 [for league competitiveness continuity], who also tried to target guys who "struggled" in their first stints, where possible):
Player 1: (AHL) 69 games, 1.07PPG
(First NHL season): 56 games, 0.48 PPG
(NHL Career-to-date): 504 games, 0.75 PPG
Player 2: (AHL) 33 games, 1.03 PPG
(First NHL season): 82 games, 0.57 PPG
(NHL Career-to-date): 415 games, 0.91 PPG
Player 3: (AHL) 34 games, 0.94 PPG
(First NHL Season): 77 games, 0.53 PPG
(NHL Career-to-date): 300 games, 0.62 PPG
Player 4: (AHL) 62 games, 1.05 PPG
(First NHL Season): 82 games, 0.61 PPG
Player 5: (AHL) 56 games, 1.04 PPG
(First NHL Season): 57 games, 0.84 PPG
5 comparable players averages:
AHL 51 games, 53 points, 1.035 PPG
(Miller): 41 games, 42 points, 1.024 PPG
First NHL Seasons following AHL season: 71 games, 43 points, 0.602 PPG
What do all 5 of those comparables have in common? For starters, they all scored 45 or more points in the NHL last season.
For those suggesting it is completely unreasonable to think Miller could contribute approximately 40-45 points next season, it is actually around the norm for players in his situation to do so. Will he? I guess that's why there is a debate. But to dismiss the possibility as altogether absurd fails to recognize that it is common enough to have 5 examples readily available from last season alone. For those wondering, the 5 players are (in order): David Krejci, Claude Giroux, Brad Marchand, Tyler Johnson, and Gustav Nyqvist. They all play different brands of hockey. They are pests, scorers, and/or play-makers. They are all different sizes and draft pedigrees. They all have different strengths and weaknesses. It's a LOT more common for a Miller to make that leap than you'd think.