We've discussed at times just what promising forwards Thompson had who haven't panned out and went elsewhere to be viable NHLers.
Some have mentioned Verhaeghe, although he had one promising season here (split between the AHL and ECHL) and was then traded by Snow for another asset Snow wished to have in the system, so he wasn't a guy we "gave up on" or anything like that. Thompson certainly didn't mess up with him. He was just starting to come into his own before being traded.
Thus, the biggest names we can think of are Dal Colle, Ho-Sang, and Wahlstrom.
Well, the latter is now kind of out of that "Thompson failed him" category. He's gonna make his way in this league and has already been important in his rookie season.
Dal Colle actually was a PPG player when he came up and he hasn't gone back down. We've all seen him a good bit and he's going to have to continue establishing himself as a lower line checking forward, because he's not going to be earning an NHL check as a scorer.
Or who knows, he may be a VERY late bloomer. But I can't watch this guy and think "Thompson botched him up".
Ho-Sang is the only one we can think of now, but he's not gone somewhere else and succeeded. In fact, he did little with the San Antonio Rampage and then went through two SHL teams this season, hardly doing a thing with either, and actually having been booted out of the first team after what, six games?
What I'm getting at is that there really is no example of a surefire talent who has worked with Thompson and seen his career simply go down the drain, only to go somewhere else and succeed. One can't sincerely come to that conclusion.
In addition, and we've mentioned this in other posts, most impact NHLers nowadays who were seen as such as prospects don't really go through the AHL anymore. The Barzals and Beauvilliers of the world pretty much go straight to the show.
HOLMSTROM:
He's the current case study. What happens to him under Thompson's tutelage?
Unfortunately, this isn't really a strong form of measurement either. Holmstrom was a surprising 1st rounder who was then brought over immediately as an 18-year-old who had missed half the season in his draft year and had 3 different injuries along the way.
This move was extremely unorthodox as you're just not going to see many NHL teams doing this, especially with Swedes who are scheduled to be playing in a combination of a very strong junior circuit and the SHL, widely considered the 3rd best pro league around. There was really no rush to bring him over and after 1.5 seasons, we can't really see any reason to have believed that he was "almost" NHL ready.
In general, there are more and more people in Sweden who are very critically looking at how NHL teams pull these kids over so early, often doing so before they've even become established SHL players. Looking over the past 10-15 years, the best Swedes in the NHL have been the ones who were allowed or managed to be strong SHL producers before coming over.