I have serious concerns for next year (2023-24)

Orfieus

Registered User
Nov 2, 2012
3,574
2,115
Atlantic Canada
My big prediction was Toronto would not make the playoffs

Toronto is 1pt ahead of Detroit and Tampa. They are 2pts ahead of Pittsburg and Washington

Toronto does have 1 game in hand with Detroit and 2 games in hand with Tampa but Toronto needs to win those for that to matter...and well, they are not winning games at the moment
 

ToneDog

56 years and counting. #FireTheShanaClan!
Jun 11, 2017
25,532
24,860
Richmond Hill, ON
Just read the title. Is next year this year or next year because we should be concerned for both. We need Tre to pull a rabbit out of his ass like Rutherford and Chevy have done.
 

Trapper

Registered User
Nov 21, 2013
24,658
12,824
Just read the title. Is next year this year or next year because we should be concerned for both. We need Tre to pull a rabbit out of his ass like Rutherford and Chevy have done.
Next year’s serious concerns are too late.
I had those 5 years ago when things should have been addressed and here we are.
Now for the most part I’m just do whatever.
This train isn’t stopping until it gets to its destination or goes off the track.
 

Gary Nylund

Registered User
Oct 10, 2013
31,158
24,573
I don't like moves Treliving has made so far

I don't like MM is still on the team, he should have been traded

I don't like AM still doesn't have a contact (I really don't like how AM is so adverse to long term contracts)

I don't like the defense AT ALL

I'd say my biggest concern is this team is going to be too complacent and I think there is a real chance Toronto might actually miss the playoffs

I have never been this low on the team, at least when Toronto was tanking we could look forward to the future, what do we have to look forward to now? Toronto hasn't done ANYTHING with this core, why should I think this year will be any different?
This was the first post of thread, seems like it's aged quite well so far.

I'll bet you right now the Leafs will finish as a top 3 team in the regular season, absolutely no chance they miss playoffs unless there are multiple catastrophic injuries. I'm talking season ending injuries to guys like Matthews, Marner, Tavares.

I'm dropping an early bet that Leafs win the presidents trophy, we've been an elite regular season team for like 5-6 years now, our division got much weaker.

This year will be different for a couple of reasons, for the first time we have a different GM with a different philosophy. We've never had a true 1LW before, we added Bertuzzi.
Whereas this post, has not aged quite so well.

Not to pick on this poster, there were many, many posters who were talking about winning the Presidents trophy and Marner getting 120 points. And while I thought we'd be weaker this season, I figured we'd still cruise to the playoffs.

We'll see what happens and there's still time to turn it around but it sure feels like the team is falling apart. My biggest concern is that the supposed leaders of the team are a bunch of cupcakes and don't seem to care whether they win or not as evidenced by Marner's latest idiotic comment that they're "doing everything right". And no, it's not all on him, the only player on the team that looks like he has what it takes to win is Rielly.
 

Leafs98

Registered User
Sep 26, 2007
457
304
This thread works for this season and next as well. Need good decisions leading up to the 25/26 season. Thats our final window (core - 11m Tavares) Just accept medocrity for this year and next til these contracts clean up (some expire this year). But need good personel decisions from now til then.
 

AvroArrow

Registered User
Jun 10, 2011
18,930
20,178
Toronto
This was the first post of thread, seems like it's aged quite well so far.


Whereas this post, has not aged quite so well.

Not to pick on this poster, there were many, many posters who were talking about winning the Presidents trophy and Marner getting 120 points. And while I thought we'd be weaker this season, I figured we'd still cruise to the playoffs.

We'll see what happens and there's still time to turn it around but it sure feels like the team is falling apart. My biggest concern is that the supposed leaders of the team are a bunch of cupcakes and don't seem to care whether they win or not as evidenced by Marner's latest idiotic comment that they're "doing everything right". And no, it's not all on him, the only player on the team that looks like he has what it takes to win is Rielly.
Feels bad man, was so optimistic going into the season. What a shit show it has been.
 

Gary Nylund

Registered User
Oct 10, 2013
31,158
24,573
Feels bad man, was so optimistic going into the season. What a shit show it has been.
I assume everyone feels bad right about now. I figured we'd be a bit worse maybe due to aging D, but still easily a top 10 team. I still wasn't super optimistic about the playoffs, and of course I have no optimism left whatsoever in that regard but still, I thought we'd cruise during the regular season.

The worst part if that I feel like we're doomed with this core at these prices and once we lock in Marner this summer, that's that and we're just doomed to spin our wheels until their contracts run out, and only then will we finally start the inevitable rebuild and I shudder to think how empty our cupboards are likely to be at that point.

It's weird how there are so many people still high on the koolaid talking about how great these players are, the greatest Leafs of all time and so on. It's like they don't care about having a winning team as long as we have a few stars they can fawn over. Weird.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AvroArrow

mjd1001

Registered User
May 24, 2022
435
394
The positive news for me. The Leafs don't play up or down to their competition so much, but they seem to have trouble against very young pr very skilled skating/fast teams (Buffalo, Ottawa, Montreal even C-bus, Edmonton) that they SHOULD beat, but its almost like they don't want to put the effort in to outskate those guys). They have played and gotten a lot of those games out of the way.

They seem to play better, 'get up' for the games against the better teams, but the ones that are 'more veteran' and don't have the pure speed/skill/skating ability. Its like if the Leafs can outskate a team without trying too hard, they do well. The schedule is tough on paper, but may actually give them better matchups.

As far as next year goes, I can't see us getting anything different than this year, last year, the year before, etc. This team is what it is, highly skilled, high scoring, but with some big time holes. They CAN make a run to the cup but they need one of those years where everything falls into place just right. As long as we have this core, and they are paid what they are paid, that is it.

Chicago, Detroit, Buffalo, Anaheim, even Carolina and Florida all are likely to have a pretty good amount of cap space in the offseason. Some of those teams are getting better, so Toronto is not going to win a bidding war, or even engage in one, for any available players that are major upgrades. This isn't the hockey version of New England with Tom Brady where players will take less money just to play here because they think they have a 50-50 shot of making the Superbowl after all...
 

LeafLoyalist

Registered User
Oct 13, 2015
252
261
Besides the big 4 getting paid $46M, and when you add Reily $53.5M, that leaves you with very little to go after quality goalies/defenceman....doesn't mean you can't get lucky, but this team hasn't developed the young players to fill in the cap with cheap contracts. If you look at the recent Stanley Cup winners they have a balanced salary cap roster, and got lucky with key players who were developed in the system with cheaper contracts. And to add insult, nearly every player has a NMC or NTC, that includes the likes of Jarnkrok, Domi, McCabe,Brodie, Kampf, Bertuzzi....there is no one left to easily trade.
 

Orfieus

Registered User
Nov 2, 2012
3,574
2,115
Atlantic Canada
woke up this morning to find Toronto is now in a wildcard spot. Frankly they are only a few losses away to being out of the playoff picture

The only saving grace is they are losing to West Coast teams right now
 

Confucius

There is no try, Just do
Feb 8, 2009
23,349
7,928
Toronto
Feels bad man, was so optimistic going into the season. What a shit show it has been.
Well we gave up players like Engvall, Mikheyev, in order to get tougher for the playoffs. Why would we expect to do better in the regular season? Problem is we may not even make the playoffs now because we were looking to toughen up.
 

Al14

Registered User
Jul 13, 2007
24,386
5,833
I'll bet you right now the Leafs will finish as a top 3 team in the regular season, absolutely no chance they miss playoffs unless there are multiple catastrophic injuries. I'm talking season ending injuries to guys like Matthews, Marner, Tavares.

I'm dropping an early bet that Leafs win the presidents trophy, we've been an elite regular season team for like 5-6 years now, our division got much weaker.

This year will be different for a couple of reasons, for the first time we have a different GM with a different philosophy. We've never had a true 1LW before, we added Bertuzzi.
Well, this post aged well. NOT !!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Wrong Wilson

BallardEra

Leafs&Caps Since 1982™
Dec 26, 2017
8,029
13,042
East York, Ontario
It seems to me that faster teams really give the Leafs problems this season. Another thing is that I see no defensive structure whatsoever. It's almost like Keefe just wants them to go out and try to outscore the opposition.

Very puzzling.
 
  • Like
Reactions: usernamezrhardtodo

JT AM da real deal

Registered User
Oct 4, 2018
12,354
7,766
It seems to me that faster teams really give the Leafs problems this season. Another thing is that I see no defensive structure whatsoever. It's almost like Keefe just wants them to go out and try to outscore the opposition.

Very puzzling.
Why are you puzzled? We drafted a skilled roster which has always lacked speed except for Willy and Rielly.

And we only have 1 top 4 NHL dman .. so our D zone play with always sucks which it has all season long

Da difference now is like I tell you guys every year .. after XMAS pro hockey changes to a faster game with less time and space on puck and it only gets worse in playoffs .. skill gets over whelmed by speed and grit .. nothing new here
 
  • Like
Reactions: usernamezrhardtodo

BallardEra

Leafs&Caps Since 1982™
Dec 26, 2017
8,029
13,042
East York, Ontario
Why are you puzzled? We drafted a skilled roster which has always lacked speed except for Willy and Rielly.

And we only have 1 top 4 NHL dman .. so our D zone play with always sucks which it has all season long

Da difference now is like I tell you guys every year .. after XMAS pro hockey changes to a faster game with less time and space on puck and it only gets worse in playoffs .. skill gets over whelmed by speed and grit .. nothing new here
Ya but the Leafs at one point had one of the fastest teams in the league.

At this point it's like they don't even know what identity they have or what team they are trying to put together.
 
  • Like
Reactions: usernamezrhardtodo

uncleben

Global Moderator
Dec 4, 2008
14,876
9,947
Acton, Ontario
When Treliving was brought in and nothing at all was changed except for some overpriced stopgaps, I think the writing was on the wall that this would be a down year

I don't imagine we'll see any major changes this season (though open to being wrong)

Despite a lot of the rhetoric here, we're not a bad team. Underwhelming, disappointing, sure, but we're not bad.
It's like many forget when we actually were bad (I swear it was almost more fun times around here back then)

We'll still walk into the playoffs.
If we win more, fantastic!, if not, I feel like Tre and Co. and will probably just shrug it off as a lost year where they got to "evaluate the team" and then make some changes.

Many of the recent Cup winners had a down "reset" kind of year before they won. I hope beyond hopes this is ours.

The "we'll still walk into the playoffs" is looking very generous, but I'm still not shocked this year is looking disappointing. Not much was done to increase hope
 
  • Like
Reactions: ACC1224

ULF_55

Moderator
Feb 27, 2002
87,158
18,867
Mountain Standard Ti
Visit site
The off-season was off.

However, to be fair.
Klingberg - he was their shot at a top 4 defender.
That was their biggest need.
I thought he looked fine, calm with the puck and not limited in the processing department.(between ears)
No he wasn't going to be a Pronger, but he could make a good decision and move the puck.

Add a top 4 defender to their existing core and you can push Brodie down to 3rd. pairing rotational status.


Now the supposed "snot" ...
They have turned into depth players.
They are not difference makers.
They are not better than what was already on the team making dramatically less.

Being what they might need in the playoffs is redundant if they can't help you get into the playoffs.
They may also be limiting potential tryouts from their "Futures" pool.

Goaltending.
Who expected the disaster in net.
It is a disaster, all they needed was okay goaltending.
Samsonov having a breakdown perhaps wasn't surprising to some, but did anyone foresee such a dramatic breakdown?


As for the contracts, don't really care at this point. Future contracts have no impact on how the team is playing now. Matthews and Nylander are playing on their old contracts, as are marner and Tavares.


As for the future, it isn't as dire as some want it to be.
However, management has to blend their knocking on the door players into the line-up, in a intelligent manner.
We know the candidates, Grebenkin, Cowan, Minten, Steeves, ..., some surprising where'd he come from.
 

JT AM da real deal

Registered User
Oct 4, 2018
12,354
7,766
Ya but the Leafs at one point had one of the fastest teams in the league.

At this point it's like they don't even know what identity they have or what team they are trying to put together.
I am not sure if I ever saw this super fast team .. Matty is a little above league average .. JT has always been slow .. Mitch is at best league average (straight line not 5ft edge burst) .. and Willy can fly sure he can skate at speed with anyone and so can Rielly
 

Gallagbi

Formerly Eazy_B97
Jul 5, 2005
49,511
12,087
I am not sure if I ever saw this super fast team .. Matty is a little above league average .. JT has always been slow .. Mitch is at best league average (straight line not 5ft edge burst) .. and Willy can fly sure he can skate at speed with anyone and so can Rielly
We were very quick in the final Lou days and even into that first year with JT. Team speed was high overall and Babs system had us skating a lot, which pushed pace, even at the expense of possession and creativity.
 

myleafs

Registered User
May 25, 2021
2,423
2,657
This thread works for this season and next as well. Need good decisions leading up to the 25/26 season. Thats our final window (core - 11m Tavares) Just accept medocrity for this year and next til these contracts clean up (some expire this year). But need good personel decisions from now til then.
so just hang on for 2 more years and trust that management will get a brain and figure it out?
 

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad