The Clear Cut Superstars McDavid is a really good pull. Value aside, the CCS' are really nice looking cards if you're a fan of acetate cards.
On a good day, that card alone almost covers the cost of the box. They are selling for 75-100 CAD on eBay right now, but it is a pretty hard pull, Clear Cut Superstars fall less than 1 per case (apparently 1:360 packs) so if they dry up on eBay, and you're patient you might be able to get a bit more for it.
I find that CCS don't seem to be as big of a hit as they should be considering how hard they are to pull. Some of the lesser names can be had for a few bucks. But because that card is a McDavid, and because it is a hard pull it has a lot of value. Long term though, I would guess it wouldn't hold its value but I could be wrong.
All those insert cards aren't really worth much. They are fun if you like the designs but in Series 1/2 they are mostly just there to beef up the set. Especially with ePack, you can buy most of those canvas and shining stars inserts for pennies+shipping on Comc and I'd imagine complete sets aren't that hard to find on eBay at a decent price.
Tkachuk is a decent YG to pull. He is going for like 5-10 CAD right now, but that'll go down after the initial release premium wears off. Otherwise, the other YGs are worth a buck or two+shipping (maybe a bit more in an in person sale).
As far as how you did, the McDavid card made the box. Anytime you even get close to breaking even let alone profiting off of a box of current year product you've done very well. Great looking card of the most in demand player right now. A very hard pull, and it could probably cover the cost or most of the cost of the box if you decided to sell it. The rest of the stuff is typical Series 1 fare. Nice looking cards, but value wise you're not looking at a killing for any of it. The McDavid made the box.
This is true. The rest combined, I don't know for sure but he might be looking at $20 bucks before shipping if he sold it all. That's the thing about series 1, there are some bigger single cards like a Matthews or Marner YG, exclusives, high glosses, etc. But if you don't hit a big card, the regular stuff you'd expect from Series 1 are worth so little that even combined you're not getting a lot of value. It seems like there aren't a lot of mid value cards in series 1/2 that might add up if you hit a few of them. Even last year, there were only a few YGs worth more than a few bucks. I haven't followed a lot of breaks for this year's product so I might be off, but last year it was comical to a point where if you didn't hit a McDavid, there was a good chance you spent 150 on 20-30 bucks worth of cards.