You were amazed by his hockey sense every time? That is actually one of his biggest question marks. Bit of a pond hockey player...for too often tried to do it all himself instead of passing to teammates.
I saw Reway play more than 20 times live..and there were games when he never passed the puck. Too his credit, and Ben Groulx, by the playoffs he was starting to figure that out..that it's easier to get scoring chances from the give and go than it is by trying to deke five players.
There is no doubt he has talent though - more than once he DID deke through every player on the other team...he has some moves and quickness that few junior players have, and he'll only get better playing under Groulx. He came a long way this past season.
Reports on him last summer were that he was a chain smoking orphan with bad habits and a bad attitude - but Groulx is getting him turned around, and he thinks Reway will be playing in the NHL by age 21.
Well, Grant, by every time I saw him I didn't mean to say that I've watched every single game he played. I watched dozens of his Q games and all of his games with Slovakia this year.
But, in the games I saw, he always seemed to caught my eye.
As for his hockey sense, I always thought he had it in him even though he wasn't showing it on a constant basis. In many of my viewings he did make quick, crisp passes to teammates who chocked the receptions or who weren't seeing the game as fast as he was. It wasn't his best attribute, but, when he did pass, I thought he could easily become better in this part of his game.
His selfishness might be due to many factors that include low hockey IQ, bad attitude, etc. But I think it is not that farfetched to think that he might become much more if he resolve some of his problems, as the last sentences of your post seem to indicate. He has it in him, he just needs to put it all together, which is a whole other story.
All in all, I just think he's a really decent pick at 116th overall. Taking him involves some risks, sure, but also he's also a guy that was over PPG this season and postseason while doing really good in his U 18 tournament. Just a solid bet, in my eyes.