Proposal: Habs - Col/Nashville/Anaheim/Edmonton
- Thread starter waitin425
- Start date
- Status
Groo
Registered User
Can't see any of the other teams saying yes
Stewie Griffin
What the deuce
John Mandalorian
2022 Avs: The First Dance
- Nov 29, 2018
- 11,495
- 7,251
IWantSakicAsMyGM
Registered User
Take out Girard and Kuemper and add the Habs unprotected 2022 1st and the Avs still say no.
This set of trades is so far removed from reality I am not even sure where to start.
There is ZERO chance the Oilers deal Dylan Holloway for Ben Chiarot. In fact, had you bothered to watch yesterdays presser with Kenny Holland he expressly and clearly stated he would not deal a 1st or a top prospect for a rental. Not just an overpay but completely the opposite of what the Oilers GM said he'd be willing to do all of 24 hours ago. Brutal.
The more I dig into the rest of these trades I see they are all just as incredibly lopsided for the Habs.
Perhaps this thread should die a quick death and get locked.
Maybe I'm reading it wrong.....Girard 5mil + Keumper 3.5 mil and Price 10.5 mil (20 percent retained) = should be close
Carey Price is yet to play this year. Gallagher is still out. Petry will make more sense to move in the summer because of his cap hit and remianing years. Chiarot is the only one that will likely be moved but I don't like the return consodering we're retai ing half the salary. I really liked Holloway but he just got surgery and haven't played in a long time... I'd prefer a late first. And then we have to take on Klefbom on top of that, jeez! I'm not the owner so I don't care, but I don't think we'd need to take dead cao back considering Chiarot already low cap hit.
Not an Oiler fan, and therefore I in fact could not have been bothered to watch Holland's presser.
Ducks in a row
Go Ducks Quack Quack
SoundwaveIsCharisma
Moderator
I think I'm okay with the inevitable 2nd round exit with Kuemper rather than that trade for Price.
So Nashville, a team that traded off their smaller players in order to get younger, bigger and more physical is giving up their recent 1st round pick in Zack L'Heureux, and next years 1st rounder for a smaller, less physical player that's not really producing, and carries a $6.5M cap hit. Please explain the logic here.
The Moose is Loose
Registered User
These trades are all awful
Is this for real??? Price at 8M for Girard and Kuemper? Try attaching unprotected 2022 + 2023 1st picks and then Sakic starts thinking.
Price isn't available he isn't being traded.
If Price were traded Montreal would likely need to retain 45 % 4,725,000 per x 4 years
Other team ?
5,775,000 per x 4 years
Last edited:
The Petry proposal is not that bad. However, I'm not sure he fills a need in Anaheim with Drysdale, Manson and Shattenkirk as RHD's...
Why would we give our best prospect for an expiring Ben Chiarot?
John Mandalorian
2022 Avs: The First Dance
- Nov 29, 2018
- 11,495
- 7,251
In that case, you’re looking at adding Chiarot + Lehkonen + 2022 1st.
So that still doesn’t get you there.
- Jul 25, 2012
- 41,747
- 38,227
Why would Anaheim trade for petry, and a 1st at that
He looks pretty old and washed up at this point, we’re looking for young players to go forward with…. I’ll take romonav for a 2nd tho
He looks pretty old and washed up at this point, we’re looking for young players to go forward with…. I’ll take romonav for a 2nd tho
Gallagher’s contract wasnt great when he was producing. He’s not producing now and I doubt any team would willingly give up a good prospect and a first to take that contract
IWantSakicAsMyGM
Registered User
- Status
