Seems to be the canned response Devils fans use in every single proposal for the 10th. If you donāt want to trade it, just say that and spare everyone the histrionics and forced outrage. Itās a 10th overall pick, not Jack Hughes. Comparable picks have been traded recently for less than I proposed here.
Oh, so thatās what this is about
. And the one involving the 2nd round pick wasnāt the proposal here.
Oh, so thatās what this is about
As for the ālist themā part, itās been mentioned in this thread already, so Iām not going to humour you pretending you donāt know.
Romanov took a big step in 21-22, a step which Xhekaj hasn't taken yet.
There are, but youād like to pretend otherwise for the sake of your narrative/argument. Got it. Itās discussed in this very thread lol.
cool, now would you mind pointing me in the direction that got you to this:
Huh? What nonsense. Romanov was traded with 133 games played under his belt averaging 19 and a half minutes a night and was a 1st unit PKer by the end of his last season in Montreal. He was very effective defensively and built like a tank. He was also still only 22 at the time and was on a much better d-core. That said, it is widely considered that Montreal fleeced NYI in that deal already.
Palat brings value in other areas when he's not scoring at least. Anderson mearly exists, and barely. What a awful comparison,
Fair enough but teams don't usually pay as much for an asset that might take that next step.
This draft is deeper at the top, imo, so I donāt feel thatās enough to get into the top 15 this year. Hence, the Mailloux + 26th offer.
That's kind of my point.
Itās really interesting how this works. Since itās a Habs player, he gets the value of his potential. Never mind the fact that he couldnāt stick in the NHL and was demoted to the AHL. No, thatās preposterous, he should be valued based on his absolute ceiling! (IE a top ten pick or more). But, when it comes to another teams player, such as Zegras, itās no longer about his potential or even the fact that heās already had 60+ points in both his first two full seasons. Itās all about his injury riddled season and will this now be the player he is going forward. In fact, because of that, heās now barely worthy a first round pick.
How many NHL games has Mailoux played? about the same as Romanov when he was traded? If you don't want a canned response how bout actually doing research on what the Devils need instead of half-assing it.
The kid might reach his potential one day and be worth a top 10 pick but until then no one is trading a top 10 pick based on potential. I mean other than using the pick to draft obviously.
I said āsomething likeā. If you donāt like it, thatās fine, but the value is more than fair, doesnāt matter what you say. Like I said, weāre talking about a 10th overall pick here, not Jack Hughes.
Palat's also negative value, maybe even more than Anderson. It ultimately comes down to Xhekaj+Avs 2nd for 10th OA which is still a terrible trade for the Devils.
no it isn't and it's laughable that you think so. There's a reason why both Hab's fans and all other fanbases never like your trade threads.
