Ernie
Registered User
- Aug 3, 2004
- 13,341
- 3,187
If Hoglander has appeal I don't think it's as a win now asset. He's more of a medium term bet.
Grub's Canucks & NHL News, Rumours, and & Fantasy GM | Christmas Presents
- Thread starter Vector
- Start date
If Hoglander has appeal I don't think it's as a win now asset. He's more of a medium term bet.
That’s fair. I more meant he’s not a pure future asset like a draft pick or prospect. Hoglander won’t help turn the Sabres or Rangers season around but would at least be in the line-up the next night.
One of samuelsson/joki will be available when dahlin gets back.
I'd go for one of them first to try and stabilize then look at bigger cloer to tdl
I'd go for one of them first to try and stabilize then look at bigger cloer to tdl
Nucker42
Registered User
- Nov 27, 2011
- 2,645
- 1,953
It’s Byram or bust for me. Would move a 1st for him.
Bourne Endeavor
Registered User
Actually, yes. Someone over on r/canucks looked up the data and showcased just how little Pettersson plays with Hughes relative to their respective skill levels.
I highly recommend reading both their posts but the gist is Pettersson still has a 50.81%xGF away from Hughes while everyone else is at 40.73%xGF overall. In other words, Miller, Boeser and DeBrusk rely far more on Hughes than Pettersson does.
Put simply, getting a legitimate puck moving defenseman would do a world of good not just for Pettersson but the team as a whole because we wouldn't have to rely on Hughes for damn near everything.
That's the fundamental problem right now, and teams recognize it. Which is why they try boxing out Hughes more than any other player. You shut him down and it shuts us down.
Last edited:
- Oct 13, 2018
- 4,683
- 5,607
Buffalo doesn't want more futures, they badly need to make the playoffs.
risky doing that. trading picks like candy and in a few years us fans will bitch and moan oh wow we havent drafted a good defenseman since quinn hughes 2017. wat if lerkermaki is on the table for short term help then what? rinse and repeat again. the core will get older. miller boeser petey. canucks are in a lose lose situation tbh
- Oct 13, 2018
- 4,683
- 5,607
Sure, that's how competing works, but I'd rather go for it than watch Hughes leave as a UFA, and Miller age out.
Competing for what? As Burkie used to say, you'd have to be in some drug-induced fantasy to think this team is a Cup contender.
And guys like Miller, Demko and Boeser 'will' age out long before that happens anyway. You don't win a Cup with just star players. It's 'depth' that always spells the difference. And this team really doesn't have any.
Canucks LB
My Favourite, Gone too soon, RIP Luc, We miss you
- Oct 12, 2008
- 79,105
- 34,170
MarkusNaslund19
Registered User
- Dec 28, 2005
- 5,802
- 8,756
Yuck.
Btw, Sabres fans absolutely detest Cozens and think quite low of Byram right now. The grass isn't always greener than the superstar who is hurt and only playing like a star.
I would be apoplectic if they made this trade.
- Oct 13, 2018
- 4,683
- 5,607
Great, find some depth.
I'd rather the team actually try to win the cup while they have the best defenseman on the planet making half his expected value.
Diamonddog01
Diamond in the rough
Bobby9
Registered User
- Feb 10, 2019
- 2,581
- 3,469
Even I wouldn't make that trade.
It would have to be Power, Cozens and JJ Peterka for EP and Hog
It would have to be Power, Cozens and JJ Peterka for EP and Hog
Mr. Canucklehead
Kitimat Canuck
I hate the idea of trading Petey. At his best he’s an outstanding player. And I feel like there’s no scenario where we win a trade involving him.
Josepho
i want the bartkowski thread back
You are way more likely to acquire a Hampus Lindholm or something with the 17th overall pick than you are to select a good player that actually lines up with this team's competitive window. I hate this idea that if there isn't an obvious move to bolster this team, we have to give up.
TruGr1t
Proper Villain
- Jun 26, 2003
- 24,816
- 9,544
I'm not against moving Pettersson (or really anyone outside of Hughes, for that matter), but you better knock it out of the park.
- Aug 28, 2011
- 18,209
- 23,085
This franchise needed him to excel and be a perennial 100 pt player to offset the deficiencies elsewhere (ie. on the blueline).
In any other market like CBJ or Carolina, this is probably a non-story and he probably rides out his contract.
We will undoubtedly lose in any trade involving him. People raise a stink about his compete level but Cozens and Tage are legitimate sloths at times.
Cozens is in his 5th NHL season, is turning 24 soon, has had ONE season over 50 points and 20 goals (2 years ago, was 5th on his team in points with 68), and is on pace for his least productive season (34 points) since his rookie year. Oh yeah, he's also signed to a terrible contract until 2030.
I'll pass on him unless Buffalo is adding a ton of value to unload that contract in a Pettersson trade.
I'll pass on him unless Buffalo is adding a ton of value to unload that contract in a Pettersson trade.
Just A Bit Outside
Playoffs??!
- Mar 6, 2010
- 18,057
- 17,895
The more I think about it, the more I dislike any EP deal with Buffalo.
thecupismine
Registered User
- Apr 1, 2007
- 2,822
- 2,404
Yup, they can play 15 minutes a game without a competent puck mover, but trying to do it for 35 minutes is a recipe for disaster. Elite with Hughes out there, contender for 1st overall pick without him.
Cole & Zadorov were still below average puck movers (on average, Z could be great some games), but there's still a big drop off between them and Soucy/Myers, and another level for the bottom pairing guys.
The team will do 90% of things right, then undo all of it with one stupid icing/pass off the boards/etc. It's frustrating to watch because the mistake is obvious, while all the correct things they're doing get ignored afterwards because of that one mistake. Forwards are being chopped off at the knees with the current situation.
The bull case is the team is a sleeping giant that gets unlocked with one more puck moving guy and other moves around the edges. The bear case is something is off with the locker room that’s leading to these inconsistent efforts, and only management really knows the answer to that.
TruGr1t
Proper Villain
- Jun 26, 2003
- 24,816
- 9,544
If you're trading Pettersson make him broadly available, I'm sure you can do better than that Buffalo package.
Trust me, if you think Petey is frustrating, wait until you watch Tage.
He’s a very low IQ, one dimensional soft center. Guys like him, Zibanejad, and Kyrou I want far away from this team.
He also, surprise surprise with these Buffalo guys, low hockey sense and is a brutal center at the NHL level.
