Duclair provided positive value because he signed for $1.6m. If that's was Duclair's demand to Dorion at the end of the 2019-20 season, we almost definitely would have re-signed him. The reason we didn't sign him was because he was likely going to arbitration. In arbitration, the comparables showed he would likely get something in the range of $3.5-4m.
Arbitration is always heavily dependent on stats. Duclair had good stats, but that it. He's also a winger (less valuable), he's also one-dimensional (less valuable), he's not a veteran leader (less valuable), he was also up for arbitration at a very uncertain time, in the middle of 2020, with a flat cap. We would have ended up with a negative value contract. The fact alone that the market dictated his value at around $1.6m instead of the $3.5-4m is proof of this. The fact that he was traded for a 5th rounder and a 4th line player at $3m instead of the $3.5-4m is even more evidence of his true value.
One dimensional middle-6 wingers are far less valuable than people think they are. These players constantly bounce around the league for so little. Just look at Zadina for example. Or, like Tolvanen, etc.
I'm sorry, but Duclair's production on a per game basis is easily worthy 3.5-4 million as was his last season with us. He would have outproduced most of our forward group.
Him not being a center or a core player and a one dimensional winger applies to both players, so I'm not sure that needed as much attention there as it got.
It would have been short term and we had money to toss around, obviously. Going to arbitration with Duclair at that award would have been a better deal than Dadonov at his contract and we wouldn't have had a negative contract because he both earned it, and would have only been for 1-2 years at a time we had the room. Dorion made a bet and it didn't work out.
No matter how you slice it, we tried to upgrade and actually downgraded, even at his potential arbitration salary. The good part was Dorion recognized quickly that Dadonov wasn't going to work out, so he dealt him and got back a placeholder and a slightly higher pick than Duclair did, much later in a different cap environment as a cap casualty. The fact he was dealt and like Dadonov returned something, and no salary coming back, says it wasn't actually a negative contract, he just doesn't fit in Florida anymore.
None of this is going to mean shit in the grand scheme of things, but I still think you're off base.