Then why has Edmonton struggled so much with prime McDavid and Draisaitl? Wasn't long ago that playoffs weren't a given.
What about the year Sid and Geno were both out for over half of it and the Pens still got 106 points? DB got the Jack Adams for that one.
I remember him using the same players as Therrien after he got canned and going 18-3-4 when he got the job to get us into the playoffs.
Yeah he wasn't perfect, but we've had far worse coaches in this organization. The way he gets mocked here is totally overblown.
Besides, a lot of these Sullivan teams have had better depth on paper than those Bylsma teams.
Bylsma era:
View attachment 603665
------------------------------------------------------
Sullivan era:
View attachment 603666
Malkin's output is similar. Sid produced like 18% more. Big whoop. Hardly enough to carry a coach with that differential when the wingers and blue lines are worse.