This team is now lacking exactly one thing: a true 1C. And, after our FA signings, the pre-draft trade, and solid drafting in the later rounds over the last couple of years, we actually now have a glut of defensemen:
McDonagh
Shattenkirk
Smith
DeAngelo
Skjei
Pionk
Bereglazov
Holden
Staal
Graves
Pedrie
Day
Zborovsky
Gilmour
There are exactly two players on this roster that I think could be moved as the centerpiece for that missing 1C: McDonagh and Skjei. They seem to have made it clear, however, that McDonagh is staying. He's the captain and both Smith and Shattenkirk listed his presence on the team as one of their principal reasons for coming aboard. Also, he's two years away from an expensive extension, at the age of thirty...
Now, I love Brady Skjei as a player and think he has a promising career as a top pair, and even potentially #1 D, ahead of him. But you can make an argument that he's even more valuable than McDonagh due to his age and the fact that he's under team control for four more years. Also, we already have McDonagh, Smith, Bereglazov, Holden, and Staal on the NHL squad who play the same position, with Graves, Day, and Pedrie (and Gilmour, though he disappointed last year) in the minors, all quite close (not necessarily for top-4 duty, but certainly for bottom pair). I also believe all our unsigned D-men but for Nanne are LHD as well.
Would you trade Skjei as the centerpiece of a deal for, say, Nathan MacKinnon? Believe it or not, he's actually two years YOUNGER than Skjei, with a fixed cap hit of $6.3MM for the next six years (a.k.a. the length of Girardi's buyout). MacKinnon's more established and has the allure of being drafted #1 OA, but defensemen are more valuable than forwards, and Skjei's contract situation is better. Is there a deal to be done straight up? How about Skjei and Hayes/Miller for MacKinnon and picks/prospects?
Thoughts?