GDT: Free Agency Day 1: You're from Boston? Come on down

Status
Not open for further replies.

CheckingLineCenter

Registered User
Aug 10, 2018
9,430
10,266
Kevin Hayes is actually genius pickup as a cap dump for a team trying to score a high pick. You cant accidentally overperform with him on the team. Country club atmosphere is simply too much for the team to overcome on the ice when Hayesy is in the room.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: Sideline

Pancakes

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Mar 4, 2011
27,477
20,080
Obviously you don't judge a cake before it's actually finished baking but I'm sorry... I gotta wonder where some of you are getting confidence in there being a plan or lane picked or whatever cliche you want to use. This all seems very confused to me, at least.

I mean it's whatever but this notion that the team has finally decided to do things one way or the other to my eyes is patently false. So far this has all the hallmarks of a "compromise roster." At least they aren't signing long term deals. Yet.
I'm not super confident that Dubas has it figured out. But he spent a lot of effort to contend last year and we still sucked, so the way I see it is at least he's accumulating assets now to rebuild with. If we suck again, it's no big loss is it? We all expect to suck anyways. At least we have our pick now.

There's zero downsides to sucking this year other than maybe it upsets Sid or whatever. And if the team somehow contends against all odds, then they did so while keeping a good set of assets to build to the future with anyways.

The path Dubas chose has no real downsides the way I see it especially if you think (as we all prolly do) that there's zero chance we can win a cup with the core.
 

Gurglesons

Registered User
Dec 18, 2009
96,400
78,328
Joshua Tree, CA
last-train-tocool.blogspot.com
Obviously you don't judge a cake before it's actually finished baking but I'm sorry... I gotta wonder where some of you are getting confidence in there being a plan or lane picked or whatever cliche you want to use. This all seems very confused to me, at least.

I mean it's whatever but this notion that the team has finally decided to do things one way or the other to my eyes is patently false. So far this has all the hallmarks of a "compromise roster." At least they aren't signing long term deals. Yet.

Well you see despite us trading a 1st and a 2nd less than 12 months ago for Erik Karlsson. We are now "rebuilding". Despite the fact Dubas just traded Jake Guentzel for Michael Bunting. We are now focused on selling everything off.

When Marcus Pettersson inevitably re-signs. It'll be because we need to have players here!

You can't just tear everything down while Sid is still hear. You have to acquire Beauvilliers.
 

Dennis Reynolds

I have to have my tools!
Jun 10, 2011
3,581
3,754
Paddy's Pub
Kevin Hayes is actually genius pickup as a cap dump for a team trying to score a high pick. You cant accidentally overperform with him on the team. Country club atmosphere is simply too much for the team to overcome on the ice when Hayesy is in the room.
I'm really not sure if he's any better of a player than his brother at this point.

I know exactly what I said.
 

Honour Over Glory

#firesully
Jan 30, 2012
81,500
45,877
The Hawks did not trade Kane until he was a rental, when their rebuild started like 3 years before that.
Crosby is in his final year aka rental to move, just as a thought. But Rust? Teams still want to acquire him. Eller was asked about at the deadline too.

Personally allowing personal feelings to keep Letang was one of the dumbest decisions by ownership.
 

BlindWillyMcHurt

ti kallisti
May 31, 2004
36,138
31,166
I'm not super confident that Dubas has it figured out. But he spent a lot of effort to contend last year and we still sucked, so the way I see it is at least he's accumulating assets now to rebuild with. If we suck again, it's no big loss is it? We all expect to suck anyways. At least we have our pick now.

There's zero downsides to sucking this year other than maybe it upsets Sid or whatever. And if the team somehow contends against all odds, then they did so while keeping a good set of assets to build to the future with anyways.

The path Dubas chose has no real downsides the way I see it especially if you think (as we all prolly do) that there's zero chance we can win a cup with the core.

The downside is that we are here in the first place and shouldn't be nor did we need to be but evidently the team just couldn't put some people's planet-sized egos in check. So I won't stop being irritated about that anytime soon as it shits all over the core.
 

Pancakes

HFBoards Sponsor
Sponsor
Mar 4, 2011
27,477
20,080
I think the downside is conversely, we're not going to suck ENOUGH more than anything else. :laugh:
I dunno we came perilously close to a lottery pick this year and now we're gonna have a full season of no Jake. Sully is still here too.

An injury to Sid or EK could see us being super bad realllly quickly. And we've been lucky enough to avoid injuries to our important players for the most part the past few years. Imagine how bad we'd have been last year if we had our normal injury luck?

The downside is that we are here in the first place and shouldn't be nor did we need to be but evidently the team just couldn't put some people's planet-sized egos in check. So I won't stop being irritated about that anytime soon as it shits all over the core.
Yeah there was a path to not being where we're at now but that involve JR, Hextall, Dubas, and Sully not screwing the pooch and well they all did.
 
  • Like
Reactions: HandshakeLine

Dennis Reynolds

I have to have my tools!
Jun 10, 2011
3,581
3,754
Paddy's Pub
Good thing we're collecting all those 2027 picks. That should help us with the rebuild in 2030.

Did I say 2030? Sorry, the plan changed, we're now rebuilding in 2034.
Yeah, you figure a kid is 18 at the draft and it's at least four years until the average player is a regular. So they expect to be contenders again post-2030.
 

SEALBound

Fancy Gina Carano
Sponsor
Jun 13, 2010
42,750
21,601


As has been mentioned, might be worth it to see if Colton could be had from Colorado. Always liked his game.

Eller or Acciari at max retain for Colton and a 3rd.

I don't think that's quite right. Landy is on LTIR so that's $7mil. I don't believe Nuke counts against them so that's $6mil. They have 13.3mil in space if I'm not mistaken.
You absolutely do. This franchise has a huge, storied history of trading off HHOFs and leading scorers to make a move. It's the very mythos of our whole 1st era-- Cullen and Zalapski for Francis, Jennings, and Sammuelsson! It's been kind of a mistake that we got away from that to be honest.
I mean, again, this is hindsight. Your best example is one of the greatest swaps in NHL history because it turned into B2B cups for the Penguins and Francis went on to be a HOF center. At the time (not sure how old you are), that was a very apprehensive trade they made and it was considered very high risk as Cullen was a better scorer and Zalapsky was a big time PMD. So yeah, a highly risky trade worked out. Great. This team has tried that over the years with good luck, most recently in 2016 - Perron/Hags and Scuds/Daley. But very rarely do teams wanting to make the playoffs and compete for cups just trade off valuable impact players. Show me an example in recent history.
Literally no one is excited that Kevin Hayes is on the Penguins. People are happy that they're finally making the difficult decisions they need to do and start the rebuild, rather than the tire spinning they've done in the past 3-4 years.

Do you think Sharks fans liked watching the Sharks as they gradually declined and sold off their top pieces? Of course not. But this is what a rebuild looks like.
"OMG WE GOT GRANLAND!" said no San Jose Sharks fan or player.
 

Honour Over Glory

#firesully
Jan 30, 2012
81,500
45,877
I'm not super confident that Dubas has it figured out. But he spent a lot of effort to contend last year and we still sucked, so the way I see it is at least he's accumulating assets now to rebuild with. If we suck again, it's no big loss is it? We all expect to suck anyways. At least we have our pick now.

There's zero downsides to sucking this year other than maybe it upsets Sid or whatever. And if the team somehow contends against all odds, then they did so while keeping a good set of assets to build to the future with anyways.

The path Dubas chose has no real downsides the way I see it especially if you think (as we all prolly do) that there's zero chance we can win a cup with the core.
Figured out?

Like it's been mentioned and reported. Dubas and Sullivan came up with a plan. Why does it look like a problem to be figured out? Because Sullivan hasn't had a plan that's worked since the cup dust settled. So every plan looks like shit.
 

CheckingLineCenter

Registered User
Aug 10, 2018
9,430
10,266
I'm really not sure if he's any better of a player than his brother at this point.

I know exactly what I said.
Like I said, he negates any fears of all of our mid cast offs having a career year at once.

Hayesy will keep the boys loose on the road! Beers on the plane in the “national”! Steak dinners… he knows a good spot in every town!

I can see the Yohe article now: “cap dump or not, Kevin Hayes is bringing much needed levity to these Penguins”

“Despite being predicted to finish in last place, the Penguins appear to be in good spirits at the start of camp. Much of that can be attributed to new arrival Kevin Hayes presence in the locker room. The Penguins were paid to take Hayes, but you’d never know that based on his play in 3 on 3 practice drills. I heard he grilled burgers at Sid’s house….”

Sorry. I’m having too much fun with this
 

JRS91

Registered User
Jul 4, 2010
2,103
1,086
The Capitals got some nice players.

Chychrun and Roy are really nice additions. I'm still in belief that Dubois is an extremely overrated player with a awful attitude.; I feel like they're going to regret that move in a few years.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Rave7215

Harvey Birdman

…Need some law books, with pictures this time…
Oct 21, 2008
9,231
2,351
Penguins Legal Office
Obviously you don't judge a cake before it's actually finished baking but I'm sorry... I gotta wonder where some of you are getting confidence in there being a plan or lane picked or whatever cliche you want to use. This all seems very confused to me, at least.

I mean it's whatever but this notion that the team has finally decided to do things one way or the other to my eyes is patently false. So far this has all the hallmarks of a "compromise roster." At least they aren't signing long term deals. Yet.
For me its more of a fatalistic and realist view. FSG picked their guy. He isn't going anywhere. We could line up outside the area with pitchforks and burn Dubas in effigy. FSG brought him in, for as long as they did. He's going to at a minimum see the length of that contract to show FSG at least his plan with a post Sid Penguins. So do I like Dubas so far? No. I don't even though I championed him arriving. But I realize he is not going anywhere. So I don't waste the time complaining about him exhaustively.
 

Honour Over Glory

#firesully
Jan 30, 2012
81,500
45,877
The Hawks did not trade Kane until he was a rental, when their rebuild started like 3 years before that.
To add to this. Kane wasn't happy about DeBrincat going and it's flashes of Sid and Jake and Sid not being happy losing Jake. Both moves started that rebuild.

They made the playoffs and were out in the first round. Then missed and were missing again and moved out Hagel, etc. Pens aren't seeing they're in the same f***ing boat and instead of doing a proper tear down, it's some mishmash shit that solves nothing and kicks the can down the road to avoid the problem that is unavoidable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gurglesons

Gurglesons

Registered User
Dec 18, 2009
96,400
78,328
Joshua Tree, CA
last-train-tocool.blogspot.com
Like I said, he negates any fears of all of our mid cast offs having a career year at once.

Hayesy will keep the boys loose on the road! Beers on the plane in the “national”! Steak dinners… he knows a good spot in every town!

I can see the Yohe article now: “cap dump or not, Kevin Hayes is bringing much needed levity to these Penguins”

“Despite being predicted to finish in last place, the Penguins appear to be in good spirits at the start of camp. Much of that can be attributed to new arrival Kevin Hayes presence in the locker room. The Penguins were paid to take Hayes, but you’d never know that based on his play in 3 on 3 practice drills. I heard he grilled burgers at Sid’s house….”

Sorry. I’m having too much fun with this

Can't wait to see them buy him a lawn mower and treat him like a franchise legend in two years.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Ad

Upcoming events

Ad

Ad