The unknown factor for Canada if they can get their rematch on Thursday is Makar. I would say Theodore too, to a lesser extent, but he isn't coming back. Canada's biggest weapon is speed but even with McDavid and MacKinnon you really need to be driving that from the blueline and Makar is the man. Just how big an impact can he have?
I understand the calls for Marchand to get more time and opportunity I'm just not seeing that he can be the difference-maker. Smart as he still is, I don't think he has the agility or explosiveness anymore to cut through elite defense. I think Canada's big-time stars are going to step up and get it done for them or not at all.
Canada will regret not selecting Logan Thompson. They can try Hill but his recent performance hasn't exactly been great either. Thompson has no claim to greatness yet himself but he is the man in form and they should have run with that. As it is they are vulnerable in net and in these tight checking games giving up even one soft goal can be a dagger. Even with all their offensive firepower Canada isn't putting 3 or 4 past the US defense and Hellebuyck.
The US started a little slow and probably let Canada push a bit too hard for stretches of the 3rd, but otherwise they played this game just about exactly as they would have wanted to. Physical, tight, a good tempo but a speed they could control, for the most part. Catching out the Canadian D on the rush when opportunities presented themselves. Protected inside ice. Hellebuyck was excellent and had to make some good saves, but he got very good coverage too.
Much as I favor the way the US team is constructed, the gap between the two is only small. If they played each other 10 times, you'd say that America would win maybe 6 of them, IMO. But there is only one final so Canada just need to bring their best on that one night and hope that's enough. Of course they have to get there first, and even undermanned if Finland plays more like they did against Sweden they will not be pushovers. That's going to be an interesting game in its own right.