Former Canucks Thread 2023-24 Off-Season Edition

[credulous]

dermott is a smart bet for the oilers. he was okay with the coyotes last season until his injury

 

[Bojack Horvatman]

https://x.com/i/web/status/1833635633388048708

that beer league team is about to be hit with a recapture penalty

 

[im gangster]

that beer league team is about to be hit with a recapture penalty

The player never had anything to do with it, just the team. /nitpick off

 

[Vector]

Aidan McDonough has been invited to the Panthers' training camp.

 

[F A N]

Aidan McDonough has been invited to the Panthers' training camp.

They love former Canucks. We used to love former Panthers.

 

[AlainVigneaultsGum]

Looks like Kass is done. Working for the Oilers now.

https://thehockeynews.com/nhl/edmonton-oilers/latest-news/zack-kassian-joins-oilers-in-new-role

 

[LordBacon]

Looks like Kass is done. Working for the Oilers now.

https://thehockeynews.com/nhl/edmonton-oilers/latest-news/zack-kassian-joins-oilers-in-new-role

Love your new profile pic.

 

[AlainVigneaultsGum]

Love your new profile pic.

 

[AwesomeInTheory]

As for Sutter, I don't think you can say he was ill-suited for the role they had in mind for him given that management and Willie had different ideas. I think management thought they were getting a durable player who can handle the tough defensive matchups while also having some offensive upside. It didn't work out that way.

I have haunting memories of First Line Sutter dragging down the Sedins.

 

[rypper]

 

[Vector]

FAKE NEWS!


He was never a Canuck.

 

[rypper]

FAKE NEWS!


He was never a Canuck.

Let's keep it to a thank you Jim.

 

[F A N]

Here’s my Canucks wouldn’t have picked Guenther had they kept the pick post.

 

[Breakers]

I still don’t understand why people Dylan Guenther would have been the Canucks pick

You think that idiot Ron Delorme would have picked him?

Guy is the worst judge of talent in the history of scouting he has 3 leagues to judge and hasn’t been able to find a shred of talent.
he would have picked Tyler Boucher if he was in the CHL during his draft year.

 

[LemonSauceD]

I still don’t understand why people Dylan Guenther would have been the Canucks pick

You think that idiot Ron Delorme would have picked him?

Guy is the worst judge of talent in the history of scouting he has 3 leagues to judge and hasn’t been able to find a shred of talent.
he would have picked Tyler Boucher if he was in the CHL during his draft year.

Zero chance we would’ve picked Boucher. He was projected as a late 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Probably would’ve drafted Guenther or Coronato.

 

[Breakers]

Zero chance we would’ve picked Boucher. He was projected as a late 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Probably would’ve drafted Guenther or Coronato.

No shot
This organization can’t scout the CHL.

 

[F A N]

I still don’t understand why people Dylan Guenther would have been the Canucks pick

You think that idiot Ron Delorme would have picked him?

Guy is the worst judge of talent in the history of scouting he has 3 leagues to judge and hasn’t been able to find a shred of talent.
he would have picked Tyler Boucher if he was in the CHL during his draft year.

Zero chance we would’ve picked Boucher. He was projected as a late 2nd or 3rd round pick.

Probably would’ve drafted Guenther or Coronato.

It was well reported that the Canucks were prioritizing centres and defensemen (which was perfectly reasonable in this draft). I believe Sillinger was the next on the list after their draft targets were gone. Sillinger would have been my pick as well. I didn't like Guenther.

 

[rypper]

https://dailyhive.com/vancouver/ex-canucks-edler-home

 

[HairyKneel]

Here’s my Canucks wouldn’t have picked Guenther had they kept the pick post.

Why did Delorme nail it in Western Canada for a lot of picks in the late 80's to mid 90's and then piss his pants for the last 20 odd years? It's bizarre really. The Canucks as a whole has shit the bed drafting out of this country.

 

[StreetHawk]

It was well reported that the Canucks were prioritizing centres and defensemen (which was perfectly reasonable in this draft). I believe Sillinger was the next on the list after their draft targets were gone. Sillinger would have been my pick as well. I didn't like Guenther.

I would agree. Also, no chance they take Wyatt Johnston. Hopefully avoid Boucher whom Ott took.

Would be fine with Sillinger as the pick. Tops out as a 2C with good solid size. Think he has more to give than what he's shown so far. Heck, some were talking MacTavish would be there and he went 3rd. Think Van fans were hoping for Clarke who went 1 pick ahead, then MacTavish/Sillinger would be next. Edvinsson, I don't recall how high Van fans were on him. Great tools, but needed coaching to get him to maximize it.

 

[tyhee]

I still don’t understand why people Dylan Guenther would have been the Canucks pick

You think that idiot Ron Delorme would have picked him?

Guy is the worst judge of talent in the history of scouting he has 3 leagues to judge and hasn’t been able to find a shred of talent.
he would have picked Tyler Boucher if he was in the CHL during his draft year.

I don't know who the Canucks would have chosen, but Delorme hasn't been a main decision maker regarding the Canucks' picks since Gillis promoted Eric Crawford to a position over him in about 2012. Folks may recall Gillis making the change and later saying one of his biggest mistakes was not making changes to the scouting department sooner.

When Guenther was drafted in 2021 I had the feeling Benning had pretty much taken over the decision making on the draft, having parted ways with Judd Brackett the year before.

Right now 2021 is looking like a bleak draft year for the Canucks. They had no picks in the 1st, 3rd or 4th rounds, extra picks and in the 5th and 6th rounds and I"m not sure the Canucks hold the rights to anyone they drafted that year other than Klimovitch and Koskenvuo.

 

[Breakers]

I don't know who the Canucks would have chosen, but Delorme hasn't been a main decision maker regarding the Canucks' picks since Gillis promoted Eric Crawford to a position over him in about 2012. Folks may recall Gillis making the change and later saying one of his biggest mistakes was not making changes to the scouting department sooner.

When Guenther was drafted in 2021 I had the feeling Benning had pretty much taken over the decision making on the draft, having parted ways with Judd Brackett the year before.

Right now 2021 is looking like a bleak draft year for the Canucks. They had no picks in the 1st, 3rd or 4th rounds, extra picks and in the 5th and 6th rounds and I"m not sure the Canucks hold the rights to anyone they drafted that year other than Klimovitch and Koskenvuo.

They should have cleaned house with anybody who had any say or input with the CHL. It's the worst scouting in the league in that area. Multiple blown top 10 picks, and nothing promising in the later rounds.

Delorme's bio for awhile said he was head of the CHL scouting and it is still what he is involved in.

I will never believe they would have chosen a quality CHL player as they didnt show it the countless years previously.

 

[HairyKneel]

They should have cleaned house with anybody who had any say or input with the CHL. It's the worst scouting in the league in that area. Multiple blown top 10 picks, and nothing promising in the later rounds.

Delorme's bio for awhile said he was head of the CHL scouting and it is still what he is involved in.

I will never believe they would have chosen a quality CHL player as they didnt show it the countless years previously.

Delorme is a figure head at this point. Like tyhee said it's been a dozen years. The guy birddoggd some players in Western Canada for a decade. But the whole dept has shit the bed since 2012 which is a good barometer to work off of. Those players are 30 and under and why exactly are these scouts missing out on good players? They do well in Europe and in the US, but they crap their pants here.

 

[Bubbles]

Why did Delorme nail it in Western Canada for a lot of picks in the late 80's to mid 90's and then piss his pants for the last 20 odd years? It's bizarre really. The Canucks as a whole has shit the bed drafting out of this country.

Delorme didn't do jack in the early years other than be a regional scout. Mike Penny was the chief scout and made some great picks.

Yes, CHL and specifically WHL and BCHL drafting has been horrid. But I didn't see any improvement in the matter by the new regime either. I hope Sawyer Mynio works out.

 

[HairyKneel]

Delorme didn't do jack in the early years other than be a regional scout. Mike Penny was the chief scout and made some great picks.

Yes, CHL and specifically WHL and BCHL drafting has been horrid. But I didn't see any improvement in the matter by the new regime either. I hope Sawyer Mynio works out.

How the hell do you know what? Guys like Valk, Scatchard, Ward, Sopel etc have come out and said he scouted them. Muckalt, Tyson Nash. There's a few more. The dude was solid for a decent chunk of time and he lost his way. We all know this. I was trying to wind the clock back a dozen years as those are the guys that really matter to the current team. Why piss and cry about shit that happened when you rocked diapers?

So you attribute the successes to Penny but bury Delorme at the same time. There's a big tent, a gaggle of makeup and some shitty wigs for you.