Roenick likes attention, and he's found a way to get some.
There's no doubt in my mind that Semin (and others on the Caps) had many stretches of lazy play over the past few years. Heck, we bash on Eric Staal for that regularly. Imagine if Eric Staal was traded to the Leafs and had a 10 game point streak. The Leafs fans would be all over this board saying how great he was and many on this board would say "Just wait until you get a stretch of lazy Staal, he's inconsistent, etc.."
While some Caps fans are bitter and go overboard, there are also a number of more reasonable ones that have lamented about Semin's effort and have seen him a LOT more than we have. I'm glad Rutherford signed him, I'm glad he's doing well here in Carolina and I hope he continues to play inspired hockey, but I'm also withholding praise until later in the season.