Player Discussion Fabian Lysell

[TCB]

Agreed. I believe a B's coach left a fairly regular player off the Outdoor game roster, for a game in their home town. Was it Krug in Michigan ? Perhaps I'm mistaken.

Frederic was scratched for a game in St. Louis his rookie year

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

On our team Donato would be 3rd in goals behind only Pasta and Marchand. He'd be 3rd in points for us too.

So I do look forward to you defending this point in some reasonable way.

And even though I STILL don't think Donato is spectacular, my point stands. We'd be lucky to see Lysell develop to this level (3rd on our team in scoring). Every single one of us in here right now prays that ends up being his best case. Because his most likely case right now doesn't look amazing.

But if Donato was actually playing for the Bruins this season, he would not have those numbers.

 

[wintersej]

On our team Donato would be 3rd in goals behind only Pasta and Marchand. He'd be 3rd in points for us too.

So I do look forward to you defending this point in some reasonable way.

And even though I STILL don't think Donato is spectacular, my point stands. We'd be lucky to see Lysell develop to this level (3rd on our team in scoring). Every single one of us in here right now prays that ends up being his best case. Because his most likely case right now doesn't look amazing.

He is a one way player that scores 25-30 points from the bottom six. He is having a hot streak this year on a brutal team, but he really has less value than some two way grinder who gives you 20 points and can PK instead.

 

[MarchysNoseKnows]

Agreed. I believe a B's coach left a fairly regular player off the Outdoor game roster, for a game in their home town. Was it Krug in Michigan ? Perhaps I'm mistaken.

Wasn’t it Bjork playing at Notre Dame?

 

[Kegs]

Donato is outscoring Taylor Hall and Tyler Bertuzzi at the moment. And he's a better 2-way player than both of them.

That said, I agree that its way too early to project Lysell's career at this point.

I strongly disagree with donato being a better two way player than Taylor hall. Hall is better at every part of the game. Donato is having a career year at 28 and out scoring hall by a couple points. Hall also came back from a bad injury last season. By the end of this season I expect halls numbers to easily pass donato.


Sorry to derail this thread.

I think lysell was literally sent back down because they down want Tom Wilson to obliterate him along the boards.

Lysell will probably see some more games this season. Let’s remain optimistic.

 

[goldenblack]

But if Donato was actually playing for the Bruins this season, he would not have those numbers.

Most would have said the same about Heinen. Or Brazeau.

 

[PlayMakers]

I mentioned last year that odds are Lysell would be Donato if he was lucky. People thought that was outrageous. I'm just saying we'd all happily take the Donato career arc now. That would be beyond what he's trending at presently.

When Donato was Lysell's age he was still in college. Lysell is far beyond what Donato was at the same points in their career arcs.

 

[goldenblack]

When Donato was Lysell's age he was still in college. Lysell is far beyond what Donato was at the same points in their career arcs.

I'm not remotely suggesting Lysell is lagging Donato, you're the only one infering that.

I'm simply suggesting that most of us NOW would take the Donato career, if it was out there. Because of all the possible outcomes on offer for Lysell, there are some much worse ones looking not entirely impossible for this young man.

 

[Dr Hook]

I'm not remotely suggesting Lysell is lagging Donato, you're the only one infering that.

I'm simply suggesting that most of us NOW would take the Donato career, if it was out there. Because of all the possible outcomes on offer for Lysell, there are some much worse ones looking not entirely impossible for this young man.

Most of us? I don't think we're anywhere close to resigning Lysell to the 'lucky to be Donato at this point' category. The guy is about to turn 22, has been putting up solid offensive numbers in the AHL and has grown his game and his body. Sure, he might be a complete bust, but I don't see how anyone can honestly say that before he's really even had a chance to play in the NHL.

 

[goldenblack]

Most of us? I don't think we're anywhere close to resigning Lysell to the 'lucky to be Donato at this point' category. The guy is about to turn 22, has been putting up solid offensive numbers in the AHL and has grown his game and his body. Sure, he might be a complete bust, but I don't see how anyone can honestly say that before he's really even had a chance to play in the NHL.

Maybe I'm not expressing this correctly, so I'll try.

if you made a poll thread in here now that said

"Would you be happy if Lysell one day was a 25 goal per season NHL player"

My sense is you'd get at least 80% of the board who would fist pump that.

Donato is probably getting 25g this year.

Are we now saying the same thing?

 

[Dr Hook]

Maybe I'm not expressing this correctly, so I'll try.

if you made a poll thread in here now that said

"Would you be happy if Lysell one day was a 25 goal per season NHL player"

My sense is you'd get at least 80% of the board who would fist pump that.

Donato is probably getting 25g this year.

Are we now saying the same thing?

Yeah, now I get it., The problem I think was the Donato comparison, because he is a not very good one dimensional NHLer, this outlier scoring season notwithstanding. If you had led with just 25 goal scorer I think you would have had everyone pretty much agreeing we'd be happy with that.

 

[goldenblack]

Yeah, now I get it., The problem I think was the Donato comparison, because he is a not very good one dimensional NHLer, this outlier scoring season notwithstanding. If you had led with just 25 goal scorer I think you would have had everyone pretty much agreeing we'd be happy with that.

But I think if you make a second poll and ask if people would take 30 pt NHL years out of Lysell at this point (aka Freddy output), most ALSO take it.

Would you put Fabian in the top 75 players under the age of 22? Don't think he's in mine. I'm not sure he's in my top 75 FORWARDS under 22.

 

[Dr Hook]

But I think if you make a second poll and ask if people would take 30 pt NHL years out of Lysell at this point (aka Freddy output), most ALSO take it.

Would you put Fabian in the top 75 players under the age of 22? Don't think he's in mine. I'm not sure he's in my top 75 FORWARDS under 22.

To me, if he ends up as a 30 point one-way forward, that to me is a basically a bust, and I'd be bummed. Unlike Freddy, he doesn't have size and (alleged) grit and physicality to make a career out of the bottom six.

As for the second part, I don't know where Fabian ranks among all NHLers under 22 because I don't know them all, especially not the ones that aren't etablished NHLers at this point. We should come back to that list in 3-5 years and see what it looks like. I imagine it will be quite different that what it would look like today.

I guess my larger objection is that so many people here are writing the kid off already when there is no real basis for that yet. He is a late first rounder so he should get the benefit of prospects taken at that spot- 3-5 years to grow into an NHLer and perhaps a bit longer to become established regulars. Is it because he opted to come to Providence instead of play in Europe so it feels like he has been in the system long enough he should be more than he is? What if he had played a couple years pro in Sweden? Or had gone to college for a couple of seasons? Would it feel different?

 

[PlayMakers]

To me, if he ends up as a 30 point one-way forward, that to me is a basically a bust, and I'd be bummed. Unlike Freddy, he doesn't have size and (alleged) grit and physicality to make a career out of the bottom six.

As for the second part, I don't know where Fabian ranks among all NHLers under 22 because I don't know them all, especially not the ones that aren't etablished NHLers at this point. We should come back to that list in 3-5 years and see what it looks like. I imagine it will be quite different that what it would look like today.

I guess my larger objection is that so many people here are writing the kid off already when there is no real basis for that yet. He is a late first rounder so he should get the benefit of prospects taken at that spot- 3-5 years to grow into an NHLer and perhaps a bit longer to become established regulars. Is it because he opted to come to Providence instead of stay in Europe so it feels like he has been in the system long enough he should be more than he is? What if he had played a couple years pro in Sweden? Or had gone to college for a couple of seasons? Would it feel different?

Yeah, he's right where he's supposed to be at age 21. Like someone else mentioned earlier. Marchand played 20 games in the NHL at 21 and didn't have a point. For most CHL drafted players, this is their 2nd year in the AHL, the year they make noise and a case for call ups.

Lysell has done that. He's a point per game AHL'er. He's made a case for himself to be called up, got called up and played a safe smart game where he helped us scored a goal. Check that box.

Honestly, it should have been enough to stick around but I get the Bruins are also managing the toughest part of their schedule and have no room for error. They have a stretch of 19 games, most against contenders, and if they're not in a playoff position a month from now the season is over.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

Most would have said the same about Heinen. Or Brazeau.

But Brazeau does play for the Bruins.

 

[Dennis Bonvie]

I strongly disagree with donato being a better two way player than Taylor hall. Hall is better at every part of the game. Donato is having a career year at 28 and out scoring hall by a couple points. Hall also came back from a bad injury last season. By the end of this season I expect halls numbers to easily pass donato.


Sorry to derail this thread.

I think lysell was literally sent back down because they down want Tom Wilson to obliterate him along the boards.

Lysell will probably see some more games this season. Let’s remain optimistic.

OK.

But Hall has never been considered a good defensive player.

In his career Donato has 211 takeaways with 127 giveaways. Hall 582 takeaways with 726 giveaways.

 

[chizzler]

I strongly disagree with donato being a better two way player than Taylor hall. Hall is better at every part of the game. Donato is having a career year at 28 and out scoring hall by a couple points. Hall also came back from a bad injury last season. By the end of this season I expect halls numbers to easily pass donato.


Sorry to derail this thread.

I think lysell was literally sent back down because they down want Tom Wilson to obliterate him along the boards.

Lysell will probably see some more games this season. Let’s remain optimistic.

Lysell was sent down because that was the plan all along no matter what happened.