There is a massive difference between saying someone didn't take over a game and calling someone a bust. My point stands that his limbs haven't fallen off and he still has the ability to outperform his peer group.
Prospect Info: F Isak Rosen (14th Overall, 2021), Assigned to Rochester 12/10
- Thread starter LastWordArmy
- Start date
-
It's Back - NHL Survivor 2024 is now open Click here to join.
There is a massive difference between saying someone didn't take over a game and calling someone a bust. My point stands that his limbs haven't fallen off and he still has the ability to outperform his peer group.
jc17
Registered User
- Jun 14, 2013
- 11,253
- 8,063
Well of course. I think saying that he tore it up might be a little heavy handed in the other direction though.
LetsGoBuffalo1126
Registered User
- Nov 17, 2021
- 189
- 286
I'm not trying to overly defend the organization, but this would be a pretty strong hindsight statement. They did address goaltender by trading for Levi and drafting Portillo. They had/have no way of knowing if these players will play for them outside of whatever conversations they have. Not taking a swing at a high-risk/reward player just because two NCAA goalies might not sign with you is strange asset management, IMO.
7 goals put him behind two players in that tournament - Michkov and Shayne Wright. Can we not celebrate this? FFS.
Also, that he can finish from a similar spot as Olofsson isn't a negative. He has the ability to finish from moderate range via skill. Prospect-wise, they only have two guys who have shown they can do that against their peers - him and (surprisingly) Bloom.
Gabrielor
Registered User
The praise on this kid's offensive ceiling was high (I heard better than Peterka), so I'll trust the development process.
I did want Wallstedt at that pick, but Tage Thompson has changed my tune on letting guys develop.
I did want Wallstedt at that pick, but Tage Thompson has changed my tune on letting guys develop.
This is like judging Samuelsson on who was taken after him. Don't put that on the player selected.
truthbluth
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2011
- 7,535
- 6,944
This Rosen-bust talk is ridiculous. A lot of great players end up having a disappointing D+1 season, and in this case it was largely not of his own making.
Looking forward to seeing him in the summer WJC and hopefully he can shut up some of the naysayers.
Looking forward to seeing him in the summer WJC and hopefully he can shut up some of the naysayers.
Hey, we all have one!
Also, I now refer to Murray as Mini-Maroon.
I've consistently wanted him to turn out, including encouraging people toward his decision to turn pro and pointing out what he does well (playmaking in confined space, getting to the net).
jc17
Registered User
- Jun 14, 2013
- 11,253
- 8,063
His performance can be celebrated, and finishing from that spot is not a bad thing.
I just don't think it qualifies as tearing it up. The implication in the reply to Sabre mike was that he was a year out from a significant accomplishment. He had good production, but I don't see that tourney performance as something so meaningful that it would change someone's opinion on the prospect substantially, or more so than the last year if that's what mike is emphasizing
WhereAreTheCookies
Registered User
The consistency of not bouncing between leagues probably would have been much better for him. Hopefully he sticks to a team next season and they don't shift him around. Allsvenskan seems like a decent developmental league in it's own right, Filip Forsberg played his D+1 season there and turned out pretty good.
Either stay in one location in the Allsvenskan or get into a situation with better use in the SHL via a loan from Leksands. Getting more playing time in a men's league is also going to be about being able to consistently perform in a men's league which was my point earlier that a full summer of training is probably better for him than going to the rescheduled U20's. Yes, the U20's are an acknowledgement but losing about a month of training time when he has so far to go is my concern.
That said, if he is there, I hope he can produce like he has done against his peers so that the conversation can shift back to being patient with him instead of him as a failed selection.
WhereAreTheCookies
Registered User
For a kid his size I agree, he just needs to add some mass and strength to his frame so he can handle a men's league. Personally I have low expectations for him since it was such a weird draft year and I see him as found money given it was in return for Risto
. Hopefully the kid turns out dynamite in a few years, but I won't be heartbroken if he doesn't.Probably a long shot but if anybody knows how to read this article for free I'd love to read it. Seems like it has some good info about what went on this season with Isak Rosen. I wouldn't even mind paying to sign up but I don't feel great about putting my info into a Swedish website when I don't even think I could understand how to cancel lol
www.dt.se
+Allt - Bonnier News
Probably a long shot but if anybody knows how to read this article for free I'd love to read it. Seems like it has some good info about what went on this season with Isak Rosen. I wouldn't even mind paying to sign up but I don't feel great about putting my info into a Swedish website when I don't even think I could understand how to cancel lol
+Allt - Bonnier News
I'm sure you'll figure it out! Let us know what is says after you subscribe! Lol.
Probably a long shot but if anybody knows how to read this article for free I'd love to read it. Seems like it has some good info about what went on this season with Isak Rosen. I wouldn't even mind paying to sign up but I don't feel great about putting my info into a Swedish website when I don't even think I could understand how to cancel lol
+Allt - Bonnier News
It basically says using some regional swedish idioms: "we have no idea what Buffalo was thinking either".
MarkusKetterer
Shoulda got one game in
Probably a long shot but if anybody knows how to read this article for free I'd love to read it. Seems like it has some good info about what went on this season with Isak Rosen. I wouldn't even mind paying to sign up but I don't feel great about putting my info into a Swedish website when I don't even think I could understand how to cancel lol
+Allt - Bonnier News
Too cheap to pay 8 kronor a week for 8 weeks before it triples in price? :p
Kublakhan
Lets Go Buffalo !!!
I was sickened when they chose this guy..
MarkusKetterer
Shoulda got one game in
I wanted Svechkov. But I’m not gonna hold that against Rosen. When he was announced I thought “who?!?!” tho
I think rosen wasn't a good choice. There was better prospects available
This pick has always not been my favorite because the skaters that were drafted directly behind Rosen were both ranked higher by consensus and had very good D + 1 seasons in comparison. Still too early to judge fully.
I have a strong conviction that we would be a far better team over the last 20 years if we fired our entire amateur scouting department and drafted off of average consensus rankings.
I have a strong conviction that we would be a far better team over the last 20 years if we fired our entire amateur scouting department and drafted off of average consensus rankings.
BloFan4Life
Registered User
I will never underestimate how much lingering injuries can truly just hamper a player.
Don't have to look far with Olofsson and look at the difference in Tarasenko.
Don't have to look far with Olofsson and look at the difference in Tarasenko.
Genny Screamer
Registered User
Rosen is a boom or bust pick, but he could be a fan favorite. He has top 6 skating, shooting and vision. He’s a long term investment that hopefully keeps growing.
truthbluth
Registered User
- Feb 2, 2011
- 7,535
- 6,944
He had a historically bad D+1. Let’s hope next season is better. I’ll reserve judgement until I see him healthy.
itwasaforwardpass
I'll be the hyena
- Mar 4, 2017
- 5,359
- 5,213
