MBH
Players Play
10 months younger is pretty irrelevant at the top of the draft. The older guys actually usually end up better in the NHL at the high end of the draft. Lafreniere is the man because he does literally everything at a high level. I'm not sure what parts of his game I would consider elite, maybe hockey sense and motor but hes a great all around player in every aspect. Byfield has never really performed at a great level in best on best tourneys.
Byfields WJC was very disappointing whereas Lafreniere was the best player in the tourney as a draft eligible. Their Hlinkas were night and day different as well. A full season worth of games is more important obviously but Byfield has never really grabbed an international tournament by the balls and said I'm willing the team to victory like Lafreniere has multiple times now. Watch the world juniors again, Byfield had no ability to change his game when moved down the line up. It was a situation where if he wasnt scoring he provided literally nothing, he didnt look engaged at times. This is expected at his age even by a prospect his calibre, but hes being compared to an even better prospect. The Canada vs USA game is a good example of what Lafreniere can do. USA is winning, he goes out an throws two huge hits, helps change momentum and goes on to have a signature game where he scores a highlight reel game winner late. He impacts the game in every way imaginable already. Byfield doesnt do that yet, he might get there but Lafreniere is already there.
He has the potential to be a franchise type winger. A comparison I've seen is a winger version of Lecavalier which I dont hate. He couldbe god enough to win some individual hardware in his career but hes not the type that will win a bunch. But hes also a great leader and will play physical to get the team going/captain material
I don't agree that a 10 month difference isn't important. I think it's huge.
Even so, I appreciate this post. Thanks.