Proposal: EDM/COL

[GhostfaceWu]

If you measure a guy exclusivly on point totals and nothing else, which only your most elementary fans can handle.

But Drai is terrible defensively and his team continues to be irrelevant other than some collection of hollow individual stats in hollow seasons.

So just like Mackinnon except with actual 100 pt seasons and hardware to back it up. Really trying to push a Mackinnon is good defensively narrative? lol.

 

[McJedi]

So just like Mackinnon except with actual 100 pt seasons and hardware to back it up. Really trying to push a Mackinnon is good defensively narrative? lol.

Mack is just a better NhL player. But in your world, hollow scoring trophies in non playoff seasons is your Stanley cup.

 

[Stealth1616]

Mack is just a better NhL player. But in your world, hollow scoring trophies in non playoff seasons is your Stanley cup.

Ya your stacked Colorado team is really accomplishing a lot

 

[Cloned]

Sather used to make these types of trades all the time lol

 

[Spilot23]

To divert from the bickering between Mack and Drai. How has Barrie looked so far this season compared to a guy like let's say Bouchard?

 

[GhostfaceWu]

Mack is just a better NhL player. But in your world, hollow scoring trophies in non playoff seasons is your Stanley cup.

Hilarious to see the narratives change from people like you. His trophy he won was during a year we made the playoffs but thanks for coming out lets go take a look at Mackinnons trophy case.......oh not even a plaque for a 100 pt season. Lmao both years the Oilers made the playoffs were only done because of Mcdavid/Draisaitl while Mackinnon had all the depth in the world and now is struggling once said depth gets taken away.

 

[Dr Amazing]

McDavid Draisaitl and a 1st round pick if not the Avs block the oilers number

 

[McYoungGuns]

Avs say no, Makar is off limits unless the name is McDavid.

Be ashamed u said those words, McDavid is off limits unless u offer all of Denver and every franchise it has had or ever had with all the players of all those franchise.

 

[Spilot23]

Be ashamed u said those words, McDavid is off limits unless u offer all of Denver and every franchise it has had or ever had with all the players of all those franchise.

Might as well just take his comment as Makar is untouchable which he is. I’m sure Drai is as well.

 

[Bone Breaker]

considering just the value in disregard of every other context involving the players and the teams, I think it is a quite fair proposal. on the videogame I think I'd try it just for fun.

 

[34]

Makar is the most valuable player here, no way Colorado does this.

 

[dahrougem2]

Be ashamed u said those words, McDavid is off limits unless u offer all of Denver and every franchise it has had or ever had with all the players of all those franchise.

You don't want Bates Battaglia, trust me.

 

[Linds]

So just like Mackinnon except with actual 100 pt seasons and hardware to back it up. Really trying to push a Mackinnon is good defensively narrative? lol.

FYI Mackinnon has averaged more points per game in the past 3 NHL seasons than Drai

 

[elitepete]

Makar >>>> Q Hughes.

What does this have to do with anything?

 

[McRpro]

FYI Mackinnon has averaged more points per game in the past 3 NHL seasons than Drai

My quick math shows 1.43 PPG for Drai VS 1.29 PPG for Mac.

 

[Linds]

My quick math shows 1.43 PPG for Drai VS 1.29 PPG for Mac.

I stand corrected for regular season. But when it really matters in the playoffs with almost double the games played compared to Drai

My quick math

Mackinnon: 1.38
Drai: 1.28

 

[McVespa99]

Mack is just a better NhL player. But in your world, hollow scoring trophies in non playoff seasons is your Stanley cup.

How many cups has Mack won? How many times to the finals? etc etc. Glass houses et all.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Avs say no, Makar is off limits unless the name is McDavid.

Lol, McDavid is offlimit unless it's Makar AND Mack coming back I guess

 

[Tobias Kahun]

I stand corrected for regular season. But when it really matters in the playoffs with almost double the games played compared to Drai

My quick math

Mackinnon: 1.38
Drai: 1.28

My quick math is

Stanley cups

Draisaitl - 0
Mackinnon - 0.

Weird.

 

[Tobias Kahun]

To divert from the bickering between Mack and Drai. How has Barrie looked so far this season compared to a guy like let's say Bouchard?

Bouchard has been miles better than Barrie IMO.

Much better offensively and defensively at 5on5.

 

[Bouboumaster]

Habs fan here, I've no horses in that race;

Makar is the 2nd best d-man in the league after Hedman
Draisatl is the 2nd best player overall (or 3rd, it depends where you place Mackinnon) after McDavid

Unless there's a add on Colorado's part, the Oilers are getting bent over in that deal

 

[Muffin]

Be ashamed u said those words, McDavid is off limits unless u offer all of Denver and every franchise it has had or ever had with all the players of all those franchise.

I wouldn’t trade Jokic for McDavid and Draisaitl combined.

 

[DingDongCharlie]

FYI Mackinnon has averaged more points per game in the past 3 NHL seasons than Drai

Wrong. Last 3 season's not including this seasons game, which if we did adds to Draisatl's lead.

MacKinnon 1.29 points per game

Draisaitl 1.43 points per game

Ugh I see someone has already called out the fallacy.

 

[josra33]

Ya your stacked Colorado team is really accomplishing a lot

Avs haven’t played one game with their full roster yet…

 

[Linds]

Avs haven’t played one game with their full roster yet…

It's okay. The oilers tank in the playoffs because they live and die with their power play.